Tuesday, October 31, 2023

613 to 10 to 2

This was preached on November 2, 2008. There has been some updating.

Much of what TV calls reality shows are anything but. Let's face it: these programs put people into extremely unrealistic scenarios. 99.9% of us will never live in a mansion with an eligible bachelor or bachelorette that we and others staying there are trying to marry. Nor will we ever be in a jungle where our survival depends on playing games. Nor will we have our spouses switched with someone who is their exact opposite in personality or personal philosophy.

My favorite reality shows are those done by the BBC or PBS in which modern people must live in a situation that is as close as possible to how their ancestors had to live. It is fascinating to see how a contemporary person or family fares when faced with a culture that lacks our modern conveniences. Especially when their survival depends, not on contrived challenges or betrayals, but on planting and harvesting crops, or drawing water, or keeping the fire going. In series such as Victorian House or Frontier House you realize just how hard our ancestors had to work. Their goal was not so much to live well, as we desire to, but to simply continue to live. In Colonial House what became clear was how absolutely vital it was for the entire community to work together and follow certain rules. If you ever wondered why sloth (laziness) was considered one of the seven deadly sins, just consider how the fate of a whole settlement was endangered if someone shirked their responsibility to do the role assigned to them.

Life in earlier times was extremely regimented and roles were strictly defined, not because everyone was a jerk, but because the entire community or tribe could be wiped out if just one person didn't carry out their duty to nurture the crops or keep the livestock healthy or repair the equipment or guard the town walls. It took almost military discipline on everyone's part for all to survive.

Similarly, things like envy or gossip or excessive drinking or violating the sanctity of your neighbor's marriage or lying or theft or disproportionate anger or disobedience to authorities could destabilize relationships and threaten the unity of the community. The resulting dysfunction didn't just hurt feelings; it could actually harm the ability of the group to work together and survive. If you've ever wondered why we have entire psalms that just praise God's law, just remember how crucial it was to the community's unity and continued existence.

Today's sermon suggestion asks, “Why do we only talk of the 10 commandments? Aren't there more?” Yes, there are. In fact, rabbis counted all the commands in the Torah, the first 5 books of the Old Testament, and came up with 613. They start right after the giving of the 10 commandments in Exodus 20 and cover things such as violence, property, restitution and maintaining just courts. A good deal of the commandments concern the making of the tabernacle or portable worship space, as well as offerings, sacrifices, the priesthood, and observing the Sabbath. There are also quite a few on dietary restrictions, like not eating pigs, vultures, shellfish and certain insects. Finally there are those which excite the most interest today: the list of forbidden sexual relations in the “Holiness Code.”

When scholars talk of the “Holiness Code” they are generally speaking of Leviticus chapters 17 through 26. The title for this section comes from the frequent refrain, “You shall be holy for I, the Lord your God, am holy.” The word “holy” means “set apart” and in regard to humans and objects it means “set apart for a sacred purpose.” These passages deal with a lot of issues, only some of which are matters of ritual purity. So chapter 17 of Leviticus concerns sacrificing animals and forbids the eating of blood. Chapters 21 through 26 concern priestcraft, tabernacle furnishings and holy days. Chapter 19, however, covers various subjects from idolatry, to making provision for the poor and resident aliens, to not abusing the disabled, to slander, to not taking vengeance on others, to honesty in business and more. It also includes the commandment, “You shall not hate in your heart anyone of your kin.” So contrary to what some say, the Holiness Code is neither completely antiquated nor entirely irrelevant to modern moral issues.

Chapter 18 is the one everybody is interested in because it contains 18 verses concerning forbidden sexual relations. Contrary to popular belief, most of them we still oppose: incest (14 verses) and bestiality (1 verse). In addition there is 1 verse condemning child sacrifice and 1 verse condemning sex between men. Note that on the basis of the number of mentions alone, you can't either elevate homosexual sex above the behaviors mentioned more often, nor dismiss it, because child sacrifice is also only mentioned once in the passage. If we single out sex between men as either exceptionally important or unimportant, we are doing so for other reasons than how often it is mentioned.

So the number of commandments go well beyond the 10 we learn in Sunday school. Why do we focus on those 10 laws? For one thing, they are mentioned first and separately from the others. And they are not only written in Exodus 20 but are repeated in Deuteronomy 5.

Secondly, they are much more general in scope and so they serve as the basis for the other commandments. The prohibition against using deceptive weights and measures (Leviticus 19:35-36; cf. Proverbs 20:10) is derived from the commandment “You must not steal.” The insistence on neutrality in the courts (Leviticus 19:15) is consistent with the commandment “You must not testify against your neighbor as a false witness.” The condemnation of making sacrifices to fertility gods flows logically from the commandment to “have no other gods before” Yahweh.

Yet the idea that the 10 commandments are the most important has been changed by Jesus of all people. When asked which of the commandments is the greatest, Jesus quotes Deuteronomy 6:5: “You shall love the Lord your God with all your heart, and with all your soul, and with all your might.” Unprompted, he adds a second one, this time from Leviticus 19:18: “You shall love your neighbor as yourself.” Then he says that all of the law and the prophets hang on these two. (Matthew 22:40) He also says no other commandment is greater than these two. (Mark 12:31)

And, indeed, you can split the 10 commandments into those that concern God and those that concern our fellow human beings. You can also boil down the prophets' criticism of their societies to these 2 main areas as well. First, they declared that the people were either worshipping other gods or not worshipping Yahweh sincerely but just going through the motions. Second, they point out that society is treating the poor unjustly. (Isaiah 1:11-17) The implication is that the second commandment flows from the first. This is something Jesus makes explicit when he says that how we treat the unfortunate is how we are treating him. (Matthew 25:31-46)

But Jesus' truly unique contributions to morals are his extensions of the second greatest commandment. Now that commandment is hard enough. It is not always easy to love your neighbor. He might be the sort of person who trims your trees without your permission, or who doesn't pick up after his dog uses your yard as its toilet, or who blasts his music both night and day. Nowhere does the Bible say you have to like him. But you must pray for him and work for his good. You might want to get to know him and understand why he does what he does. The odd thing is if you do the things someone would naturally do if they cared about someone else, eventually you will come to care about that person after all.

But in the Sermon on the Mount Jesus says, “Love your enemies and pray for those who persecute you.” (Matthew 5:44) Here he is extending the circle of those we must love. He is including not just the person next door, or your coworker, or your acquaintance, all of whom might annoy you a bit. He is saying you must act lovingly towards someone who acts maliciously towards you. Don't hate him or ignore him but love him, says Jesus. Pray for him. As Paul and Peter put it, don't repay evil with evil but repay evil with good. (Romans 12:17, 21; 1 Peter 3:9) That's a tall order and it may take you some time to be able to fully achieve it. But we must do it. After all, that's what Jesus did while we were his enemies, opposing his will for us and for the world. We are afraid to do the same because it seems to be too costly. It was for Jesus.

And on the night he was betrayed into the hands of his enemies, Jesus gave his disciples a new commandment: “Love each other as I have loved you.” (John 13:34) Here Jesus extends the standard by which we are to love others. No longer are we to do so in the imperfect way we love ourselves. We are to follow Jesus' example and love others in the same self-sacrificial way he does.

Since Jesus' 2 greatest commandments, and especially his 2 expansions of the 2nd one, are so far reaching, are we excused from obeying the rest of the 613? Yes and no. Jesus makes a distinction between human rules and God's laws and between laws concerning rituals and laws concerning moral issues. And there is a difference between observing the letter of the law—fulfilling it technically—and obeying the spirit of the law—acomplishing what it was intended to do. (2 Corinthians 3:6) So Jesus touched the sick and the dead even though it made him ritually unclean. He healed on the Sabbath and let his disciples pluck the heads off grains though the Pharisees said that violated the commandment not to work on the Sabbath. In response, Jesus said that the Sabbath was made for the sake of humans; humans were not made for the sake of the Sabbath. (Mark 2:27) For Jesus, a law should benefit people, not harm them.

This principle is also central to Paul's thinking. Among the things that Jesus' sacrifice on the cross freed us from were aspects of the Torah that simply differentiated Jews from Gentiles: circumcision, the dietary laws, Sabbaths. These cause division in the body of Christ where there is no Jew or Gentile for all are one in Christ. (Galatians 3:28) Christians now live by grace. But that doesn't mean we can disregard morality. The same Spirit who inspired the authors of the Old Testament now lives in Christians and guides them, if they let him. The moral law is to be internalized. And Paul is not shy about spelling out how Christians should and should not live.

The principles that stand behind the written laws in the Bible are still valid but the ways they are manifested in each time and culture may vary. For instance, in Paul's day a prostitute would cut her hair and did not wear a head covering in public. So Paul says a woman can prophesy in church provided her head was covered. (1 Corinthians 11:5) A woman having an uncovered head no longer means she is a prostitute in our culture, so we don't require head coverings in church. Modesty is expressed differently. Again I remember when tattoos were seen as a sign that a person had loose morals. Now tattoos are so common that what they used to signify is no longer true. And who knows what the fashion will be by 2050? But it will never be acceptable for a Christian of either sex to wear certain lewd and crude and belligerent T-shirts sold nearly everywhere these days. The principle is that Christians should not send mixed messages about their personal morality and it is still valid. Its expression, however, has and will continue to change.

This means there will be clashes at times between aspects of contemporary culture and Biblical morality. Sometimes we are called to stand out in contrast to a culture gone wrong. As did certain Christians during the civil rights movement in this country and as did members of the Confessing Church in Nazi Germany. They rightly understood that there was a clash between what the 2 great commandments said and what authorities did to oppress certain ethnic and racial groups.

There is still value in studying the commandments of the Old Testament, even if we no longer follow some of them. With a good commentary we can understand why they were important issues in their day. You will also be surprised, as I have been, by how enlightened such ancient laws were on some topics. It is also a good mental and spiritual exercise to tease out how each is an expression of the principles of the 10 commandments and in turn, the 2 greatest commandments.

One last word on this. And it is the word “command.” We still call the laws in the Bible commandments. But this obscures the fact that they are commands from our King. The moral commands are not optional. We are commanded by Jesus to love God with all we are and all we have and to love all others, including our enemies, as he loves us. Like the strict laws our ancestors followed, we disregard the laws to love at grave risk to our community and our lives. They, like the restful Sabbath, were given for our benefit. Because the law to love God and others is itself an expression of love. In obeying it we find true freedom to be God's beloved children.

No comments:

Post a Comment