The scriptures referred to are Luke 10:25-37.
The 12 tribes of Israel voluntarily united into one kingdom under David. (2 Samuel 5:1-3) It remained a single kingdom under his son Solomon. But Solomon's splendor came at a heavy price. When the northern tribes went to his son Rehoboam and asked that he lighten their burden, he ignored his advisers and said he would make things harder for them. In response to his harsh answer, the 10 northern tribes broke away and formed their own kingdom, which they called Israel. (1 Kings 12:1-16) Samaria was chosen as the capital of the northern kingdom of Israel. The southern kingdom, which was ruled by the kings of David's line, was called Judah. This split took place around 930 BC. In 722 BC, the kingdom of Israel fell to the Neo-Assyrian Empire. This was seen as a punishment from God for the idolatry they practiced. The elite of Israel and the people the Assyrians saw as useful were taken into exile and then exiles from other conquered lands were settled in what used to be Israel. (2 Kings 17:21-24) These foreign people intermarried with the poor Israelites who were not taken into exile and left behind.
Eventually their descendants, the Samaritans, developed their own worship of the God of Israel. Alexander the Great allowed them to build their temple on Mount Gerizim. They adopted as their sacred scriptures their version of the Torah, the 5 books of Moses, and excluded the other books of the Hebrew Bible. During the Maccabbean revolt against Antiochus Epiphanes, one of the successors of Alexander, the Jews destroyed the Samaritan temple in 128 BC. In Jesus' day there was still animosity between the Jews and the Samaritans, which the Jews considered half-breed heretics.
The reason I am telling you this is because today's readings include the parable of the good Samaritan. Jesus' audience were Jews. The person asking Jesus about eternal life is a scribe, an expert in the Jewish law. His question is how does one inherit eternal life?
Jesus, as he frequently does, answers a question with a question. “What is written in the law? How do you read it?” And the law expert goes to a fairly obvious verse: Deuteronomy 6:5. It is part of the Shema, the central prayer of Judaism. It starts with the verse before the one the scribe quotes: “Listen, Israel: the Lord is our God, the Lord is one!” (Deuteronomy 6:4) It goes on to say we are to love God with everything we are and have. Most rabbis of Jesus' time would agree that this is the greatest of the commandments.
The scribe then offers a second commandment, this one coming from Leviticus 19:18, where God says “You must not take vengeance or bear a grudge against the children of your people, but you must love your neighbor as yourself. I am the Lord.” In other words, God is saying, I am serious about this; remember who commanded you to do it.
When Jesus was asked which commandment is the greatest, he answered with the same two passages. (Mark 12:29-31; Matthew 22:37-40) We don't know if the scribe had come to the same conclusion or whether he had heard Jesus say this and was trying to sound like he agreed. Because after Jesus commends his answer, the man asks a further question: “And who is my neighbor?”
Now why would he ask this? Luke says that he is trying to justify himself. But about what? He probably had a rather narrow definition of who his neighbor was. At the time the Jewish people were divided into several factions.
The Pharisees believed that the written law, the Torah, and the Oral law, the traditions that came from various rabbis' interpretations of the law and how they applied to everyday life, were of equal authority. That's why they were nitpicky about the way Jesus' disciples washed their hands and why they thought his healing people on the Sabbath violated the commandment against working on that day. But they did believe in eternal life and that people faced either punishment or reward after death.
The Sadducees were the priestly party. They held that only the written law, the Torah, was authoritative. They did not believe in an afterlife.
The Essenes were an almost monastic group who held all their property in common and usually did not marry. They spent their time worshipping and studying the Torah. They were so obsessed with purity that they took frequent ritual baths. If the Dead Sea scrolls are any indication, they thought all other Jews were corrupt and they were waiting for Jerusalem's fall and a final battle between the sons of light and the sons of darkness. Most scholars think they lived in Qumran in the desert, away from other Jews.
Then there were the Zealots. They opposed Herod and the Roman occupation of Judea. They believed only God was their king. They were militant and during the Jewish war against the Romans, they took over the temple in Jerusalem and turned it into a fortress.
The scribe, probably a Pharisee, is trying to justify being neighborly to those who are like him and agree with him and looking for an excuse to not do the same to Jews who differ from him. Human beings have always divided the world into “Us” and “Them.” That was a common attitude then and it is common now. We have politicians who say they hate other Americans who do not support them. They accuse them of wanting to destroy the country. There is a move to take away citizenship from those born in this country because their parents were not.
Perhaps in telling the parable that defines who God considers to be our neighbor, Jesus was thinking of a verse in the same chapter of the book of Leviticus that the scribe cites. Only 15 verses after telling us to love our neighbor God says, “When a foreigner resides with you in your land, you must not oppress him. The foreigner who resides with you must be to you like a native citizen among you; so you must love him as yourself, because you were foreigners in the land of Egypt. I am the Lord your God.” (Leviticus 19:33-34)
So Jesus tells his Jewish audience a story. He starts with a common occurrence. A man going down from Jerusalem to Jericho was attacked by robbers. Jerusalem is almost 2500 feet above sea level and Jericho is about 800 feet below sea level. So in a distance of about 17 miles you do go down over 3000 feet. It's a very twisty road through narrow rocky passages and gorges, the perfect place for robbers to hide. William Barclay adds that the man must have been very foolish to go alone rather than as part of a caravan. Five centuries later, it was still called the “Red or Bloody Way.” So the idea that a man would be attacked on the way was something Jesus' audience would accept.
They would also accept that a priest and a Levite would head along that road. Jericho was, among other things, a residential community for priests and for the Levites who served them. And they would have believed that the priest and the Levite would walk around the man they saw rather than help him. Jesus said the man was half dead. Touching a corpse would leave a man ritually unclean for 7 days, so that he could not serve at the temple. (Number 19:11) The Levite may have been thinking the same thing. But Jesus says that they were going down the road, in other words, going home and away from Jerusalem and the temple. Their service was over. Being unclean would be an inconvenience but their rotation at the temple was over. To paraphrase Barclay, their rituals meant more to them than the suffering of another person.
Barclay does point out that they may have been worried about their own safety. Sometimes robbers would stage a scene in which one of them would pretend to have been a victim of attack. If someone stopped to help, his confederates would jump that person and rob him.
Now Jesus' audience, knowing the rule of three in storytelling, may have expected the next person to be a common Jewish man. But Jesus pulls a plot twist. The next person is a Samaritan. Now Jesus' audience would be thinking, “Oh, no! Things have gotten worse! This villain is going to finish off the victim!” But, no. When the Samaritan sees the man he is “moved with pity.” The Greek word means to have a gut feeling of compassion. And surprise! This heretic half-breed is the hero of the tale!
Jesus says that first the Samaritan approaches the man. Neither the priest or the Levite checked to see if the victim was dead or not and thus would not necessarily have rendered them unclean. The Samaritan doesn't just feel bad for the guy and offer thoughts and prayers. He jumps into action. As Martin Luther King Jr. said, the priest and the Levite asked themselves what would happen to them if they went to the man. The Samaritan asked himself what would happen to the man if he didn't go to him.
Next he gives the victim first aid. Our ancestors weren't stupid. They didn't know about germs or the antiseptic qualities of alcohol and oil but they did know from practical experience that putting oil and wine on wounds and bandaging them helped a person heal. The Samaritan used the knowledge he had to help.
Next he gets the man to safety. They are in the wilderness. They can't call 911. There are no ambulances. So the Samaritan puts the man on his donkey and takes him to an inn.
And he doesn't just dump him and let him become Someone Else's Problem. He continues to care for the man. This victim probably costs his rescuer a night's sleep.
But he costs him money, too. The Samaritan can't stay but he gives the innkeeper the equivalent of 2 days' wages and instructions to take care of the man until he returns. If it costs the innkeeper more, the Samaritan will reimburse him.
Finally Jesus asks the expert in the law which of the 3 men seemed to be a neighbor to the victim. The scribe can't even bring himself to say the word, “Samaritan.” Instead he says, “The one who showed him compassion.”
What do we learn from this?
First, your neighbor is not necessarily someone like you. He doesn't have to be of the same race or the same religion or the same country as you. He doesn't have to be anyone you know. He is anyone you encounter who is in need. And today, you may encounter him or her in the news or on the internet because distance is not the factor it was in Jesus' day. You can help people across the world through charities and aid organizations. That they aren't nearby is not an excuse.
Second, the reason your neighbor is suffering is irrelevant. The man was foolish to travel that road alone. The Samaritan didn't determine why the man was in that situation; he took care of him nonetheless. When Jesus' disciples asked him if the reason that a man was born blind was his sin or his parents', Jesus didn't assign blame. He saw it as an opportunity to serve God by healing him. (John 9:1-3) Neither does Jesus bring up the reason why the people in the parable of the sheep and goats ended up hungry or naked or sick or in jail or a foreigner. We are to take care of them regardless and serve Jesus. (Matthew 25:31-46)
Third, we are to offer practical help to our neighbor. As James says, “If a brother or sister is poorly clothed and lacks food, and one of you says to them, 'Go in peace, keep warm and eat well,' but you do not give them what the body needs, what good is it?” (James 2:15-16) As it says in 1 John, “Little children, we should not love in word or with our tongue but in action and in truth.” (1 John 3:18) In the parable the Samaritan does not say “I want you to know that I love you, my neighbor, as I do myself.” He simply demonstrates it by loving actions. To paraphrase James, creeds without deeds are dead.
Today when so-called Christians are talking about “the sin of empathy” or “toxic empathy,” I wonder how they square this with Jesus' command, “In everything, treat others as you would want them to treat you, for this fulfills the law and the prophets”? (Matthew 7:12) That requires empathy: understanding and sharing the feelings of others.
Lack of empathy is the real problem that Jesus is addressing in this parable. It is typical not to have empathy for those different from us. Right now I imagine most of us are more concerned with the more than 120 people who died in Texas last week than the 56,000 people who have died in Gaza over the last two years. But to Jesus they are all our neighbors. We are to love all of them. We are to serve all of them, not just with our lips but with our lives.
What would we do if they were people we already love and care for? We would go to their rescue. We would take care of their needs.We would help them in any way we could, even if it costs us in time, effort and money. So, as Jesus says, “Go and do likewise.”