Is God Good?

The scriptures referred to are Ezekiel 33:7-11, Romans 13:8-14 and Matthew 18:15-20.

I had just finished Karen Hao's eye opening book, The Empire of AI, about how the race for artificial general intelligence has created a globally exploitative and extractive system that copies colonialism, and decided I needed to read something lighter. So I found the audiobook, Mythos, Stephen Fry's delightful retelling of the stories of the Greek gods, read by the author himself, acting out all the parts. And then I realized that I had switched from a book about men with godlike wealth and influence who don't care about the harm they do to fellow human beings to mythical gods who don't care about the harm they do to human beings. The Greek and Roman gods were petty, cruel, capricious, vengeful, lustful, incestuous, murderous, cannibalistic and all round terrible beings. Zeus is so incensed that Prometheus has given the gift of fire to humans that he decides not only to torture his former friend forever but to drown the human race. Not because of human sin and violence as in Genesis 6:11-13 but just out of spite. When that doesn't kill them all, Zeus gives Pandora a container as a wedding gift and when she opens it, all the miseries of life, like poverty, famine, disease and despair, escape into the world. Cadmus, the first hero, slays a water dragon who has killed 4 of his men only to find it is the favorite of the war god Ares and thus is cursed to become a snake. A priestess of Zeus is seduced by the king of the gods only to be killed by jealous Hera, Zeus' sister and wife. Small wonder that the story of Jesus, revealing that God is in fact just and loving, was received as good news in the ancient world.

Unlike the Greek gods, whom you might unknowingly offend, the Bible reveals that God has told us what is right and what is wrong. We are to love both God and our neighbor. (Deuteronomy 6:4-5; Leviticus 19:18) Things that violate those two laws—stealing, lying, infidelity, wanting what doesn't belong to you—are wrong. (Exodus 20:1-17) Murder is wrong because humans are created in the image of God. (Genesis 9:6) In our passage from Ezekiel, the prophet is to warn people from doing things that will lead to their deaths. Even before Jesus comes, we see that God is forgiving. He takes no pleasure in the death of sinners but wants all to turn from their sins, their destructive and self-destructive thoughts, words and actions, and turn to him, the God of life.

In our Gospel reading, Jesus gives us a practical, step by step method of dealing with someone who sins against you. The goal, you will note, is to bring about reconciliation. Paul likewise is telling Christians that we are to love one another. Love, he points out, does no wrong to a neighbor. So what do you think that Jesus and Paul would say to Christians who feel that God's top priority is to punish sinners and who have no problem with actions that are cruel, vengeful and lead to misery and death for others?

Such “Christians” remind me of the infamous Westboro Baptist Church which would send protesters to funerals of gay people, victims of AIDS, military veterans and disaster victims. Their preacher, Fred Phelps, felt that these were punishments from God for tolerating homosexuality. The church's website featured a clock counting off how many people were going to hell every minute. They said that even Ronald Reagan and Mr. Rogers were in hell for not being outspoken against the bankrupt values of the US. Weirdly, they didn't even believe that what they were doing was warning people so they would repent as Ezekiel was doing. They believed that these people were predestined for hell and that it was impossible for them to repent. So why did they spend so much time and effort making their signs and traveling to funerals and other events? To gloat?

I read a book by Lauren Drain, a woman raised in the Westboro Baptist Church and whenever she questioned the church's leaders about verses on forgiveness and love, she was discouraged from exploring such topics. She left that church, as have 4 of Phelps' own children and about 16 of his grandchildren. Ironically, Phelps himself was excommunicated by his own church when he told the people who owned the house across the street and who painted it with an LGBTQ rainbow, “You're good people.” His grandson said that the church considered that “rank blasphemy.”

There are some preachers who prefer the picture of Jesus from the 19^th chapter of Revelation over the picture of him we see in the Gospels. In Revelation 19, we are told, he is on a horse and “He is dressed in a robe dipped in blood and his name is the Word of God.” (Revelation 19:13) They think the blood on his robe is the blood of his enemies. But the majority of the times that blood is mentioned in Revelation it's either the blood of the martyrs or the blood of the Lamb of God, that is, Jesus' blood. (Revelation 1:5; 5:9; 6:10; 7:14; 12:11; 16:6; 17:6; 18:24; 19:2) (We can discount the references to the sea or the moon turning to blood as obviously not literal.)

He also has a sword but it is not on his hip; it comes out of his mouth, as it does in the earlier vision of Jesus in Revelation 1:16. This is not an actual sword but a symbol of the Word of God. The Word of God is called the “sword of the Spirit” in Ephesians 6:17. And Hebrews 4:12 says the Word of God is “sharper than a two-edged sword.” (Compare Isaiah 49:2) Indeed earlier in Revelation we are told that when the angels triumph over Satan, “they overcame him by the blood of the Lamb and the word of their testimony...” (Revelation 12:11) Their testimony to whom? Jesus, of course, the living Word of God. So Jesus is not pictured anywhere in scripture with a literal sword, nor is the blood on his robes that of his enemies.

Yet the default picture in many people's minds seems to be that all gods are vengeful and not very loving when it comes to human beings. Sadly, that's true of many Christians. And because they think that God's top priority is punishing sinners, they think that should be their top priority as well. As someone once said, their approach to evangelism is like saying, “Have you heard the good news?” And when someone answers, “No, what is it?” they respond, “You're going to hell.” That is not good news!

However, that attitude explains why most of our entertainment seems to be about good guys seeking out and punishing bad guys. Today, to keep our heroes from looking as if they are partaking in genocide, they mostly kill robots, monsters and aliens. But even in the movie The Matrix, which is arguably an allegory in which Neo is the Jesus of that world, he kills a lot of people. And we are told that if you die in the computer world of the Matrix, you die in real life. According to the List of Deaths Wiki, in the first film Neo kills 15 people, mostly in the lobby scene. Over the four Matrix films, he kills 86 people. Jesus' body count: 0. Or if you count the people he raised from the dead: -3.

Our bloodlust is probably part of the reason that of the 3 books of Dante's Divine Comedy the most popular is the Inferno. Dante gives us a pretty comprehensive collection of sinners, including some of his political enemies, each suffering some devilishly appropriate eternal punishment in hell. Yet none of those fiendishly clever tortures come from the Bible. They come from the human imagination.

Our Creator has given us incredible intelligence. We can use it to create things that make the world better for others. But a lot of human ingenuity has been expended in creating new ways to harm and kill each other. From rocks to spears to swords to guns to bombs to flame throwers to drones to AI weapons which decide whom to target on their own, we have as yet not exhausted the ways to wage war on each other. And from beating to impaling to crucifying to drawing and quartering to waterboarding to electrified gloves, we keep coming up with more ways to cause pain and suffering. During World War 2, the Axis powers did horrific medical experiments on prisoners. And starting in 1953, our CIA had chemist Sidney Gottlieb, whom they called their “poisoner in chief,” give people powerful drugs, like LSD, without their knowledge or consent, in order to achieve their goals of mind control and more effective interrogations. Some of those unwitting subjects lost their minds and even killed themselves.

It seems to me that in viewing gods as vengeful and cruel, people were only projecting their own terrible traits onto beings more powerful than they. Let's face it, if humans had magical powers, it would be disastrous. In 2025, there were 42,348 gun deaths in the US. Imagine what the number of deaths would be if, as in the Harry Potter world, you could kill with a word. In the real world, Superman would most likely be a murderous tyrant. No wonder the ancients thought the gods must be dangerous for us to encounter.

That's why God had to reveal himself as just but merciful, forgiving and abounding in steadfast love. And when his written word wasn't getting through to enough people, he sent his Son as the living Word of God, the last word on what God is really like.

So why didn't Jesus stay and set up a physical kingdom as the Jews thought the Messiah would do? For the same reason a wise parent has to let their children grow up and learn to live as an adult in the world, using the principles they taught them. You want your children to become good people in their own right. They won't learn to use their own judgment and do the right thing on their own if you are always hovering over them. God wants us to become good people, not because a king of the world is right there, watching you. He wants us to want to do right, even when it seems like no one is looking. He wants us to do what's right because we love him and we love one another. He wants us to be like Jesus. (1 John 3:2)

But he knows that is difficult. So God sent his Spirit to live in us and guide us. And because he knows it is not good for humans to be alone, he gives us the church, the community of those who follow Jesus. As Jesus said, “where two or three are gathered in my name, I am there among them.” We are called to be the body of Christ, the ongoing embodiment of the Spirit of Christ in the world, doing the things that Jesus did. Because you know what is more effective than merely telling people about Jesus? Demonstrating his presence in our lives. Jesus healed and fed others. He told us that how we treat the poor, the sick, the imprisoned and the resident foreigner is how we treat him. In his parable of the sheep and goats, those who neglect to help the destitute, the diseased, and the despised are excluded from his kingdom. (Matthew 25:31-46)

Because no kingdom, no nation, can flourish if it is turning on its own people or neglecting them. It's not that God won't let certain people into his paradise; it's that he cannot let in those who harm others because then it wouldn't be paradise. Put Hitler in heaven and it would be hell for him. For one thing there would be too many Jews there. But more importantly nobody in heaven would be worshiping Hitler—or any other despot. Nobody would be treating him as more special than anyone else. Heaven would be hell for any narcissist or any arrogant person. And he would try to make it hell for everyone else.

Nor would God force anyone to live eternally with him. Because God is love and love requires consent. (1 John 4:7-8) As C.S. Lewis pointed out, there are people who say to God, “Your will be done,” and people to whom God will in the end have to say, “Very well; your will be done. You don't want any part of me. So be it.” As Lewis said, everyone will get what they wish for; some will not like it.

A lot of folks think the God of the Bible is no better than the Greek and Roman gods. Even ignoring the Old Testament and going back to Revelation, they fixate on the disasters and the plagues there. They read that a third of the world will be on fire and the waters will become poisonous and they see them as supernatural acts of God. But if you read the news, you can see that we are doing these things to ourselves. They count the 7 bowls of God's wrath mentioned in Revelation. (Revelation 16) They don't count the 11 times in the same book that there is a call to repent. (Revelation 2:5, 16, 21, 22, ; 3:3,19; 9:20, 21; 16:9, 11) Forgiveness is still possible. They focus on the depiction of the end of the world and ignore the creation of the new heaven and the new earth. They focus on the people excluded from the new Jerusalem, people who, if turned loose, would turn it into a hell. (Revelation 21:8) They don't pay attention to the fact that God himself will live with his people. More importantly, they miss the part where “He will wipe every tear from their eyes. There will be no more death or mourning or crying or pain.” (Revelation 21:4) That was God's goal for our world all along, to restore it to a place where he could once again pronounce everything good. (Genesis 1:31) Oh, and the hand that will wipe away those tears will still have the marks of the nails, the sign of the love that the true God, our incarnate, crucified and risen Lord, has for us.

Two Ways

The scriptures referred to are Romans 12:9-21 and Matthew 16:21-28.

There is a meme on the internet that says “Hollywood has spent $600 million trying to get Matt Damon home.” They are referring to his roles in Saving Private Ryan, Interstellar, The Martian and now The Odyssey. This last is the movie version of the epic poem about how it takes 10 years for the hero of the Trojan War to make his way back home. The reason given in the film is that by offering the wooden horse as a gift to the citizens of Troy and using the warriors hidden inside to open the gates and let the Greeks sack the city, Odysseus, King of Ithaca, violated Zeus' law. As his son Telemachus puts it, “Zeus' law tells us to treat strangers as we'd be treated because they might be gods in disguise.” This made-up term stands for the real principle of hospitality in the ancient world. It sounds like a mix of the Golden Rule and what it says in Hebrews 13:2: “Do not neglect hospitality, because through it some have entertained angels without knowing it.” Of course, in the film the law is given lip-service but not really practiced, much as the Golden Rule, some form of which is found in nearly every religion, is similarly “more honored in the breach than the observance.” (Hamlet, Act 1, Scene 4)

A principle more in evidence in the ancient world was that of seeking glory. The story of Odysseus' trick with the Trojan horse makes its way to his home long before he does. Rhapsodes, ancient reciters of poetry, perform it for the suitors who have invaded his home to seek the hand of his queen and presumed widow. Odysseus is a legend in his own time. Meanwhile the man himself is facing gods and monsters while also suffering from what we would call today moral injury. This is a form of complex PTSD we see in warriors, first responders and nurses who have to witness, live with or sometimes make decisions that go against their moral values and who they thought themselves to be. But this doesn't stop Odysseus from slaughtering his wife's suitors, who have also violated Zeus' law. This leaves him dishonored for his actions and he goes into exile. This ending wasn't in the poem but it is in the movie and it makes sense in the honor/shame culture of that time. Oh, and I apologize for spoiling the plot of a nearly 3000 year old story.

The Middle Eastern setting of the Bible was also an honor/shame culture supporting hospitality and one in which men sought glory. Winning fame and defeating your enemies was a sure way to gain glory. Which is why what Jesus has to say to his disciples in today's Gospel reading strikes them as just wrong. The popular idea of the Messiah was that of a warrior-king like David, who drove the Philistines out of Israel. The Jewish people of Jesus' day wanted someone who would drive the Romans out. The idea that the Messiah would “suffer at the hands of the elders and chief priests and scribes and be killed” made no sense. David died of old age, having established a secure kingdom and a dynasty. Jesus is saying that he would soon encounter opposition from the religious authorities, suffer and die. But what good was a dead Messiah?

Peter, who had just said that Jesus was the Messiah, the Son of the living God, takes him aside and tells Jesus he's wrong. He says Jesus doesn't understand his call from God. Which is why Jesus' reply is so harsh: “Get behind me, Satan! You are a hindrance to me, for you are setting your mind not on divine things but on human things.”

I don't know why the NRSVue uses “hindrance” rather than the more literal translation of “stumbling block.” Jesus is saying that Peter, whom he nicknamed the rock, is now a stumbling block, an obstacle to his mission. Which is why he calls him “Satan.” The Hebrew word “Satan” literally means “adversary.” It's more a title than a proper name. Jesus sees in Peter's suggestion an echo of the three temptations he faced in the wilderness. The first two boiled down to using his divine power for himself and his own ends. In the last temptation Jesus is shown all the kingdoms of the world and told they will be his if he just bows down and worships God's adversary. (Matthew 4:1-11) And certainly that would be easier than getting nailed to a cross. Why give up your life? Every other conqueror gained his kingdom or spread his empire by forcing others to give up their lives: both the lives of his own soldiers and the lives of the soldiers on the other side, plus any civilians that get in the way. That is the way of the world. That is how it is done. Jesus is saying “No” to all that.

Jesus was called by God to do something new. Rather than shedding the blood of others to force people to become part of his kingdom, he will let his own blood be shed to found a kingdom where becoming a citizen is voluntary. Rather than establishing a kingdom with borders to guard, Jesus is establishing a kingdom with no borders, a kingdom of God with no limit to its extent...other than in the hearts of those who reject the all-encompassing nature of God's love.

But that bothers some Christians. Acting self-sacrificially as Jesus did seems like a less certain way to establish God's kingdom than just using power. If you use power and the fear of your power, you can more reliably get people to do what you want. But that doesn't change people's hearts. The God who is love wants people to love him and love others. (1 John 4:7-8) You can't accomplish that with fear. As it says in 1 John, “There is no fear in love, but perfect love drives out fear, because fear has to do with punishment. The one who fears punishment has not been perfected in love. We love because he loved us first.” (1 John 4:18-19) As it says in 1 Timothy, “For God did not give us a Spirit of fear but of power and love and self-control.” (1 Timothy 1:7) The Spirit of Christ offers us self-control, not control over others.

And Jesus' way definitely calls for self-control. He says, “If any wish to come after me, let them deny themselves and take up their cross and follow me.” He didn't mean that symbolically either. He knew that doing things his way, the way of disowning yourself, making painful sacrifices and loving and serving others, would put you in direct conflict with those who insist on their own rights, are unwilling to give up anything and do not love others but wish to make others serve them. Some people, including some Christians, see Jesus' way as suicidal. And, in a way, they are right.

Jesus says, “For those who want to save their life will lose it, and those who lose their life for my sake will find it.” Most of the apostles will die for spreading the good news of Jesus. Emperors will have them beheaded or crucified. They will be killed by the sword (Acts 12:2). They will be stoned to death. Early Christians were interrogated, tortured and executed if they didn't renounce Jesus. Nero had Christians set on fire as torches to light his garden. Decius targeted bishops and clergy for arrest, torture and execution. Diocletian also had Bibles burned and churches destroyed. But instead of wiping out Christianity, the good news of Jesus spread.

Why? Because of the part of Jesus' statement that the disciples were ignoring here. They were so shocked by his statement that he would suffer and die that they didn't hear or couldn't wrap their heads around what else he said: that he would “on the third day be raised.” Without that part, his statement of how they must deny themselves and take up their cross makes no sense. Martyrs may be admired for their moral stand but few will emulate them. Because dead is dead.

But not with Jesus. Every Gospel tells us Jesus raised the dead. There was Jairus' daughter, there was the son of the widow of Nain, there was Lazarus. (Matthew 9:18-25; Mark 5:22-42; Luke 7:11-15; 8:41-56; John 11:1-44) And when Jesus rose again, all of a sudden his teachings made sense. Turning the other cheek, loving your enemies, giving to any who ask without expecting repayment, and not worrying about food, drink or clothing make no sense if this is the only life you get. (Matthew 5:39; 6:25; Luke 6: 35-36) In that case, you should grab for all the gusto you can get. And grab someone else's gusto because if there's no afterlife, there are no eternal consequences to what you do. Jesus' ethics only make sense if there is an afterlife and a just but merciful God who “will repay everyone for what has been done.”

There are consequences in this life as well. As Jesus says, “For what will it profit them if they gain the whole world but forfeit their life? Or what will they give in return for their life?” Many a person has worked all their life for the rewards of this world and then found at the end that they squandered their time and shortchanged their families and friends for stuff that is ultimately hollow, for titles and plaques and monuments to themselves that no one else will care about. How does he who dies with the most toys win anything other than the same hole in the dirt as everyone else? And if there is a life beyond this one, that person will have lost more than their earthly toys. They will have lost the life that truly is life—eternal life with God. (1 Timothy 6:17-19)

There will be rewards in this life as well, but their value will not show up on a balance sheet. One will be peace. As Paul puts it, “the peace of God that surpasses all understanding will guard your hearts and minds in Christ Jesus.” (Philippians 4:7) In times of turmoil, such peace of mind is invaluable. Being in Christ means there is peace between us and God, between us and others and peace with ourselves. The struggle to be what we are not, to fill the hole in our life with things whose shiny newness will fade, and to try to find a meaning to our existence will be resolved.

Peace, “shalom” in Hebrew, means not merely the absence of conflict but also fullness of health and well-being. Having a sense of purpose in life is a vital part of mental and spiritual health. Serving God and your fellow human beings with the gifts, talents and skills you have brings a well-being which empty and aimless pursuits do not bestow.

Having a supportive community of fellow Christians who “love one another with mutual affection” is a blessing many are missing in today's epidemic of loneliness. People are slowly realizing that humans were not meant to interact with one another primarily through screens. We are embodied creatures with different lived experiences and we need to be in contact with others so we can share our joys, our sorrows, our perspectives, our wisdom and our uniqueness. We need to find others to whom we can say, “You, too? I thought I was the only one who felt like that.” We also need to encounter folks whose experiences are so different from ours that it widens our view of the world and expands our understanding and compassion for other people. The neighborhood church is fast becoming the only place where folks can get to know people from different races, cultures, social strata and points of view.

That's what we see in our passage from Romans. One major difference between Jesus and Paul is that Jesus was the innovator and author of our faith and Paul was the person setting up, managing and helping satellite communities of Christians live as the collective body of Christ. Jesus set out the principles and Paul was working out how to implement them practically in the wider world. And we can see how Paul is spelling out how Christ's self-sacrificial love is expressed in different circumstances. “Rejoice with those who rejoice; weep with those who weep. Live in harmony with one another; do not be arrogant, but associate with the lowly; do not claim to be wiser than you are. Do not repay anyone evil for evil but take thought for what is noble in the sight of all. If it is possible, live peaceably with all.” Paul knew firsthand that Christians would run into opposition but they were not to go looking for it. If they suffered they were not to seek revenge but leave it to God. “Instead, 'if your enemies are hungry, feed them; if they are thirsty, give them something to drink, for by doing this you will heap burning coals on their heads.'” He is quoting Proverbs 25:21-22. It's a tough saying to interpret but in view of Paul's saying not to repay evil with evil, and other ancient texts of the time, I take the coals to be a symbol of the burning shame that will come upon a person for acting so badly towards someone who only does them good.

In the end of the film, even if Odysseus does feel bad about how he treated the Trojans, he does not change how he acts. He slays a room full of his enemies. He is still a man of war. And yet he sees that this will lead to the decline and fall of Greek civilization. We love to tell his tale but the wise do not emulate him. Wise people do emulate Jesus. Though Jesus' way defies worldly wisdom, people know deep down that healing is better than harming, mercy is better than vengeance, forgiveness is better than feuding and loving is better than hate. 

Rock Solid

The scriptures referred to are Matthew 16:13-20.

In Flannery O'Connor's book Wise Blood, among the eccentric characters is a conman who is promoting what he calls “The Church of Christ Without Christ.” There have been a number of con artists who have stepped into the pulpit, preaching bizarre versions of the gospel, but few are brave enough to say outright that they are trying to establish a Christianity without Christ. Yet that is what happens when Jesus Christ is moved out of the center of the faith and someone or something else is substituted. We have seen versions where the main focus is a political agenda, or the worshiper's personal prosperity, or an idea of personal empowerment taken from new age or new thought, or the con artists themselves. The problem is, when you remove Jesus, you get either a watered down or distorted version of God's good news or you get a cult.

That's the issue in today's gospel reading. Jesus has taken his disciples to Caesarea Philippi, well north of Galilee. It is the source of the Jordan river, at the foot of Mount Hermon, the probable site of the Transfiguration. Rebuilt by Herod's son Philip and named after the emperor and himself, it was a very pagan region. It had been named Paneas after the Greek god Pan, who had a shrine in a cave there. There were niches that held statues of the Nymphs, minor nature deities. Jews avoided the place. The only reason I can think that Jesus took the disciples there was to get them away from other Jews while he asked them a crucial but controversial question.

He eases into it by asking them “Who do people say that the Son of Man is?” “Son of Man” is Jesus' preferred designation for himself. He uses it more than 80 times in the Gospels, far more often than he uses the term “Son of God.” It's interesting that today we have gotten the meaning of the two titles reversed. “Son of God” was a royal title used of David and his line of kings. (Psalm 89:20, 26-27; 2 Samuel 7:8-18) “Son of Man,” while it could just mean a human, recalled the figure in Daniel 7, where it says, “I was watching in the night visions, and with the clouds of the sky one like a son of man was approaching. He went up to the Ancient of Days and was escorted before him. To him was given ruling authority, honor, and sovereignty. All peoples, nations, and language groups were serving him. His authority is eternal and will not pass away. His kingdom will not be destroyed.” (Daniel 7:13-14) “Son of man” was a Messianic title and yet, because of the ambiguity, Jesus was able to use it without getting immediately arrested.

So when asking who people thought the Son of Man was, Jesus could have just been asking who people in general thought was going to be the Messiah. Some thought it would be John the Baptist brought back to life, or Elijah, who had gone to heaven in a chariot of fire, or any one of the prophets of old. So Jesus gets to the essential question: “But who do you say that I am?” Peter immediately replies, “You are the Messiah, the Son of the living God.” Which is to say that Jesus is the promised prophet, priest and king anointed by God to restore and rule the people of God.

And Jesus congratulates Peter for getting this right, though it was not the realization of his own unaided brain but a revelation from God. Then, playing on the nickname he gave Simon, he says you are a rock and on this rock I will build my church. Some think Jesus meant the church was built on Peter, making him the first pope. This is unlikely. Peter would deny Jesus 3 times. (Matthew 26:69-75) He would waffle on whether Gentile Christians had to obey the Jewish dietary laws. (Galatians 2:11-14) As good as Peter was, does it make sense to make one fallible mortal the foundation of the church?

So what is the rock on which Jesus will build his church? Earlier in Matthew's Gospel, at the end of the Sermon on the Mount, Jesus says, “Therefore everyone who hears these words of mine and puts them into practice is like a wise man who built his house on the rock.” (Matthew 7:24) Here it is Jesus' words which are the rock. In 1 Corinthians 10:4, it says “the rock is Christ.” And in the Old Testament, God is called “the rock of Israel.” (Genesis 49:24) and “my rock, in whom I will take refuge.” (Psalms 18:2) It is more likely that Jesus is saying that what Peter stated--that Jesus is the Messiah and God's Son--is the rock on which the church is built.

People keep trying to replace Jesus with other things as the foundation on which the church should stand. They try to substitute positions on certain political or economic or social or moral issues as the real basis for Christianity. They forget that without Jesus these issues have no divine basis. Issues come and issues go. In the Middle Ages, the important issues were iconoclasm, the “filioque” clause and the authority of the pope over princes. In asserting that last issue, popes placed whole countries under an interdict or mass excommunication. In the 1300s, there were 3 men claiming to be pope who were excommunicating each other and the followers of each. Yet scripture says “...there is one God, and one mediator between God and humans, the man Christ Jesus.” (1 Timothy 2:5) Ultimately Christ is the person through whom we are reconciled to God.

Some people make the Bible the foundation of Christianity rather than Jesus. How is that bad? Because they fail to realize that the Bible is not God or Jesus but a witness to God and Jesus. Besides, the Bible has 66 books and 31,000 verses. People can and do pull verses out of context to justify thoughts, words and actions that go against what Jesus taught. For example, like the history of mankind, the Old Testament is full of wars. If a leader wants to justify his war, he can find some verse that seems to work. He just has to overlook the verses about God wanting to end war or David being unable to build the temple because he is a man of war. (Psalm 46:9; 1 Chronicles 22:8) Some people quote verses that apparently justify killing those who offend or oppose God. But they have to turn a blind eye to Jesus telling Peter to put away his sword when he was trying to keep Jesus from being arrested by his enemies or Paul praying for followers who had left him and the faith. (Matthew 26:52; 2 Timothy 4:16) People have also used the fact that many of the patriarchs had multiple wives to justify polygamous arrangements while conveniently ignoring the disharmony and jealousy we see in all of those plural marriages. (Genesis 29; 2 Samuel 13 and 16) There is no idea so awful or so weird that someone has not found a way to back it up with a verse they have manipulated.

Some folks get clever and try instead to change Jesus to fit their pet interpretation. So Jesus becomes a political rebel or an Eastern mystic or a capitalist or a socialist or a motivational speaker for human potential. Thomas Jefferson believed Jesus was merely a moral teacher and so he took two Bibles and a pair of scissors to create his own Bible by cutting out the parts he liked and pasting them in a notebook. He left out the miracles and anything saying Jesus is divine. And he's just one of the many people who have been editing Jesus for the last 2000 years.

Like the search for the historical Jesus. Bible scholar Luke Timothy Johnson pointed out that none of the results of these searches have come up with a unanimously accepted version of the man. Besides, he says, it is the Jesus of the Gospels who has impacted history and people's lives, not the ones people construct out of pieces of him and pieces of whatever is novel or currently popular. The Jesus we read in the Bible may not be the Jesus everyone thinks they want but he is the one we need.

Jesus then said that his church, built on the bedrock of him and his mission, will be able to endure against the gates of Hades. And that cavern in Caesarea Philippi which was dedicated to Pan, the god from whom we get the word “panic,” was thought to be a gate to Hades, the abode of the dead. Jesus is saying that his church will stand against the powers of death and decay.

But Jesus knows he will not always be with the disciples physically. He would die, rise again and ascend to his Father in heaven. He would pass the torch to these disciples and their successors. So he says, “I will give you the keys to the kingdom of heaven, and whatever you bind on earth will be bound in heaven, and whatever you loose on earth will be loosed in heaven.” What does that mean?

Let's look at some parallels in Jesus' teachings. In Matthew 18, Jesus says, “If your brother sins against you, go and show him his fault, just between the two of you. If he listens to you, you have won your brother over.” Jesus goes on to say if he won't listen, bring one or two other people as witnesses, so it's not just your say-so. If he refuses to listen to them, take the matter to the church. If he still refuses to listen, “treat him as you would a Gentile or a tax collector.” After that Jesus repeats that “whatever you bind on earth will be bound in heaven, and whatever you loose on earth will be loosed in heaven.” (Matthew 18:15-18)

A few things to note here. First, Jesus is not saying this is what you do if your brother annoys you or offends you. This is about sinning against you. Using the list of sins Jesus gave us last week, this would mean things like “murder, adultery, sexual immorality, theft, false testimony, slander.” (Matthew 15:19) Jesus is saying this is what to do if your brother does something wrong that harms you. Or, I think it's safe to say, if he harms someone else, especially someone who cannot stand up for themselves like a child. (Matthew 18:5-6)

Secondly, you should try to resolve the matter privately if you can. Only if that doesn't work, should you bring in others and then as few as possible. If that doesn't work, only then does it rise to the level of bringing in the church as a whole. And if the person still doesn't repent, they are to be not punished but simply shunned. As you see, such a serious decision doesn't rest on one person's feelings.

Thirdly, the purpose, Jesus says, is to win back your brother. You are trying to bring him back into a good relationship with you, not trying to get him cast out. You are not looking for revenge but reconciliation.

Finally, when the risen Jesus first appears to the disciples he breathes on them and says, “Receive the Holy Spirit. If you forgive anyone their sins, they are forgiven. If you do not forgive them, they are not forgiven.” (John 20:22-23) So this binding and loosing is not about changing rules but about forgiving people.

Which makes sense. Jesus is not telling his disciples that they can change the commandments he gave them on earth and expect that those commandments will subsequently be changed in heaven. He is not granting them the authority to change the moral laws of the universe. He is saying that what they forgive on earth will stand up in heaven and what they do not forgive will hold up in heaven. Remember in the Lord's prayer, we ask God that his will be done on earth as it is in heaven. We are not praying that our will on earth should override God's will in heaven.

Jesus knows that the disciples and those who come to him through them will screw up. He is saying that they have his permission and authority to resolve these matters themselves. They are to use their discernment and listen to his Holy Spirit in deciding how to act in matters where someone sins against someone else. Repentance leads to forgiveness; refusing to acknowledge that you harmed someone will not.

That reflects the Jesus who is the rock-solid foundation on which the church is built. He is just but merciful; he is loving and forgiving. He seeks to reconcile us to each other and to God. He is the one whom God anointed to be our prophet, priest and king. We are to listen to his word, go to him as our mediator with God, and obey his commands. The greatest of those commands are to love God with all we are and all we have and to love our neighbor as we love ourselves. Which means loving anyone we encounter, including our enemy. (Matthew 22:34-40; Luke 10:29-37; Matthew 5:44) Jesus not only taught that, he lived it. He did not fight his enemies. (Luke 22:49-51, 63-65) He even forgave them from the cross. (Luke 23:33-34)

People tend to confuse Jesus with a political partisan or a philosopher or an economist or, God help us, with John Wayne. Then they try to build movements on that shifting and unstable sand. In times of trouble we need someone who is timeless, a polestar to guide us through the raging storms. We need the Jesus found in God's word, the Jesus who is the living Word of God, who shows us what God is really like and what we, through him, can become.

No Exceptions

The scriptures referred to are Isaiah 56:1, 6-8 and Matthew 15:10-28.

Scrolling through social media today is like drinking from a firehose. You can nearly drown from all of the news, videos, links and ads that you are exposed to. On the one hand, you learn that they cured a person in New York of sickle cell anemia, that they have reintroduced beavers into Scotland, that there is a group of high school kids who volunteer as pallbearers for veterans who die without family, that AI was used to generate a bacteria-killing virus and that a man known for playing Santa in a small town in Virginia donated one of his kidneys to a stranger who needed a transplant. On the other hand, you learn that an Indiana councilman was arrested for child rape after being on the run for 2 years, that 2 middle school students were caught planning a robbery with homemade firearms, explosives and a tactical vest with white-supremacist imagery, that a popular actress was in an abusive relationship with a popular rock star that started when she was a teen, and that it seems that no one in our government can stop our government from doing bad things. C.S. Lewis pointed out that it seems that you can't say anything either bad enough or good enough about life. Why is that?

Jesus gave us the answer 2000 years ago when he was asked about why his disciples did not wash their hands before they ate. (Actually, it was probably not that they didn't wash their hands but that they didn't wash them in the elaborate traditional way that the Pharisees did. They washed from the fingertips to the wrist, then scrubbed with a fist, then rinsed from the wrist to the fingertips. There was no germ theory then; this was to cleanse you from accidental ritual contamination from contact with others you may have touched in the street or marketplace, or worse, from contact with Gentiles.) Anyway, Jesus responded by saying that it isn't what goes into the mouth that defiles a person but what comes out of the mouth. This offended the Pharisees and on the face of it, sounds disgusting. But Jesus explains that what really defiles a person is the evil things that come out of the heart. “For out of the heart come evil intentions, murder, adultery, sexual immorality, theft, false witness, slander.” In the parallel passage in Mark, Jesus' answer includes greed, malice, deceit, envy, arrogance and folly. (Mark 7:20-23) All of these start in the heart, which was considered the center of a person's thoughts, emotions and will, and then they manifest themselves as evil words and actions.

There is a tendency in human thought to locate evil in something external to us. The Gnostics thought the physical world and even our bodies are evil. Only spirits are pure. For a lot of people the source of all our problems is “those people.” And those people can be anyone you don't like: gays, blacks, foreigners, Jews, the poor. “Those people” can be those who think differently than us: the Communists, the Republicans, the Democrats, Hollywood elites. Or it's a whole industry: Big Pharma, social media, tech bros, AI. If we just get rid of “those people” all of our problems would be solved.

But they wouldn't. Because all of those people and the groups they are in and the companies they run have one thing in common with us: we are all human beings. And if there is one Christian doctrine that can be objectively proved to be true it is that human beings are flawed. It's not just that we are limited in what we can do. It is that no mere human being is morally perfect. We are susceptible to doing the wrong thing. And while sometimes we may do it inadvertently or out of ignorance, other times we do it knowing full well that it is wrong and that it will harm us or others or our relationship with others. As Paul says in Romans, “For I don't understand what I am doing. For I do not do what I want—instead, I do what I hate....I do not do the good I want, but I do the very evil that I do not want!” (Romans 7:15, 19)

We've all been there. You are tempted to eat not one but a whole sleeve of Oreos, sabotaging your diet. Or, more seriously, you are tempted in the heat of an argument to say something you know will trigger an enraged reaction from your sibling, spouse or coworker. Or you are tempted to sleep with someone you know you shouldn't, though one or both of you are married and it could break up relationships and families. Or you have figured out a way to cheat a system, customer or partner. Or you decide to get a person to do something that's wrong just to see how much power you have over them.

Of course, there will be consequences. Some of these things are crimes, violations of the written laws by which society organizes itself to keep peace and make people safe. Some are sins, moral violations of how we should act. Not all sins are crimes and not all crimes are sins. Crimes have legal consequences. Sins have moral and spiritual consequences. They change you. They affect those around you. Read enough biographies and pretty soon you learn how important, creative and famous people, some of whom you may admire, have ruined their lives and those they purport to love without breaking any human laws. Charles Dickens, who wrote movingly about people dealing with moral issues in books like A Tale of Two Cities, A Christmas Carol, and even a life of Jesus Christ for his kids, left his wife for a young actress, took his children with him and tried to have his wife put away in an asylum. Eugenics, the idea that society should eliminate negative inheritable qualities through selective breeding and even forced sterilization of “inferior people,” was supported by people such as Teddy Roosevelt, Margaret Sanger, W.E.B. Du Bois and even Helen Keller, who succeeded in life despite being both blind and deaf. Eugenics was only discredited when the Nazis showed what taking it to its logical end would lead to. I'm sure you can easily think of any number of celebrities and leaders in business, politics and even religion who have been exposed for doing very bad things. All humans, Paul said, have sinned and fall short of the glory of God. (Romans 3:23) No exceptions.

Jesus came to save us from our sins, not only through redemption and forgiveness but also through spiritual transformation. Laws and moral rules do not make people good. The only way to do that is to change the person. In 2 Corinthians Paul says, “...if anyone is in Christ, he is a new creation. The old things have passed away; look, they have become new.” (2 Corinthians 5:17) Being a Christian is about becoming more Christlike.

Which does make you wonder what Jesus is up to in the second part of our gospel reading. A Canaanite woman comes to Jesus asking for mercy for her daughter. Well, not so much asking as shouting. And we are told, “But he did not answer her at all.” The disciples are getting annoyed and tell Jesus to send her away. Jesus tells them, “I was sent only to the lost sheep of the house of Israel.”

Now if Jesus was just any Jewish man of that time, this would not be unusual. But just 7 chapters before we read that Jesus healed the servant of a Roman centurion. Surprised by his faith in Jesus' ability to heal without having to come and lay hands on the sick, Jesus says, “I tell you the truth, I have not found anyone in Israel with such great faith. I say to you that many will come from the east and the west, and will take their place at the feast with Abraham, Isaac and Jacob in the kingdom of heaven.” (Matthew 8:10-11) Jesus knows that Gentiles will be at the heavenly banquet. Shortly thereafter he heals two men in the largely Gentile region of Gadara. (Matthew 8:28-34) Jesus also healed Samaritans. (Luke 17:11-19) So why is Jesus being so standoffish with this Gentile woman?

Now Jesus was right in that his mission at that time was to Israel. But he foresaw a time when his message would go out to all the nations. (Acts 1:8) And as we see in Acts 10 even Peter was slow to realize that the good news of Jesus was also meant for non-Jews. Jesus may have been giving the disciples a chance to get a head start on what would be the next phase of their mission. (Matthew 28:19-20)

Yet the disciples' solution is to send the woman away. That was also their solution to the 5000 hungry people: “Send them away.” And Jesus told them, “You give them something to eat.” They had just returned from their mission to preach and heal. I think Jesus really wanted them to use the power he had granted them to feed the people. But in response to what he told them, they balked. I wonder if Jesus' uncharacteristic reluctance to heal this woman's daughter was also a test for them to do it themselves. But again, they don't do anything except complain.

They did not see that there is a pattern in God's plan. People who were originally excluded from being part of God's people are eventually welcomed as recipients of his grace. The Moabites and their descendants were excluded from the assembly of the Lord for what they did to the Israelites. (Deuteronomy 23:3-6) Yet Ruth, a Moabite, becomes the grandmother of King David. (Ruth 4:13-17) There was longstanding enmity between the Jews and the Samaritans. Yet Jesus, rather than avoiding their territory, went through it. He talked of spiritual matters to a Samaritan woman. She had also been married many times, something Jesus condemned. (Matthew 5:32) Yet she, and through her the whole village, came to believe Jesus was the Savior of the world. (John 4:1-42) Jesus even makes a Samaritan the hero of what is arguably his most famous parable. (Luke 19:25-37) Eunuchs also are excluded from the assembly of the Lord. (Deuteronomy 23:1) Yet the first foreigner to become a Christian will be an African eunuch (Acts 8:26-39) The pattern is clear: people once excluded from God's community later get included. As Peter says after being led by God to preach the gospel to a Gentile family, “I now truly understand that God does not show favoritism in dealing with people, but in every nation the person who fears him and does what is right is welcomed before him.” (Acts 10:34-35)

So I can only conclude that, like at the feeding of the 5000, Jesus was trying to get the disciples to do what was right on their own initiative. When they fail, he does it.

The Canaanite woman kneels before Jesus and says, “Lord, help me.” Jesus' reply, while jarring to us, was very much in character with Jewish sentiments at that time. He says, “It is not fair to take the children's food and throw it to the dogs.” And indeed Jews did compare the Gentiles to dogs, whom they saw as wild scavengers who ate anything. However Jesus does not use the word for full grown dogs but for little dogs or puppies, which Gentiles kept as pets.

The woman takes Jesus' words and gives them a twist. “Yes, Lord, but even the puppies eat the crumbs that fall from their master's table.” Touche! And Jesus, who liked to flip the script on his opponents, appreciates how this woman turned his words back on him. I imagine he smiled at her retort. So he says, “Woman, great is your faith! Let it be done for you as you wish.” And her daughter was healed from that moment.

This reminds me of another difficult passage: God telling Abraham to sacrifice his son Isaac. Abraham was about to do it when God stopped him, providing a sacrifice in place of Isaac. It was a very dramatic and memorable way to show that Yahweh was not that kind of god who demanded that of us (Leviticus 18:21) and that if a sacrifice was called for he would provide it. Which we see in how Jesus, God Incarnate, makes the greatest sacrifice by taking upon himself the consequences of our sins and the sins of the whole world, in order to open the way to reconciliation with God. Through Jesus we flawed human beings can become the people we were created to be: bearers of the image of the God who is love.

I think this encounter with the Canaanite woman was an enacted parable, like the sacrifice of Isaac. Jesus takes a situation in which the typical outcome, in this case the rejection of an outsider, looks like it is inevitable and then he changes it. Jesus lets us see that this foreigner, like the centurion, has placed great faith in him. She will not give up on getting Jesus to heal her daughter. And he rewards her persistence. And I'll bet he knew his disciples would remember and record this event when they later encountered others who were previously excluded from the people of God but who nevertheless put their trust in Jesus. God does not show favoritism. As he says in our passage from Isaiah, “the foreigners who join themselves to the Lord, to minister to him, to love the name of the Lord, and to be his servants...” are welcome on his holy mountain. He says, “for my house shall be called a house of prayer for all peoples.” The Bible's most famous verse says, “For God so loved the world...” Not just a part of it. Not just some of its people. God made us all. Jesus died for us all. He loves us all. So how should we respond? By loving him back. And by loving all the other people God made. No exceptions.

Vital Truth

The scriptures referred to are Romans 10:5-15.

In the first Sherlock Holmes story, Watson is trying to figure out what it is his new roommate does for a living. Holmes is profoundly knowledgeable about chemistry, knows a lot about poisons and anatomy and has an immense knowledge of sensational literature. He knows almost nothing about contemporary literature, philosophy or astronomy. One thing Watson is surprised to find out is that this genius does not know that the earth revolves around the sun! Holmes explains that it doesn't make a bit of difference to him and his work. There is evidence in later stories that Watson is wrong about Holmes' knowledge on some of these subjects. But this illustrates a difference in the value of certain beliefs. Remember the controversy over the demotion of Pluto? For most of us it does not matter whether it is classified as a planet or a dwarf planet. It is irrelevant to our lives. On the other hand, beliefs about the efficacy of vaccines are extremely relevant. We see this in that even the vaccine skeptic running our health system is now saying parents should get their children vaccinated against measles, a disease which has hit a 35 year high in its spread. Getting vaccinated can reduce the risk of severe complications like pneumonia, brain swelling, permanent loss of sight or hearing and even death by 97%. Not believing in the risk reduction which vaccines give can have dire consequences.

The reason I bring this up is because of verse 9 in today's passage from Romans 10. Paul writes, “...if you confess with your mouth that Jesus is Lord and believe in your heart that God raised him from the dead, you will be saved.” This is a vital verse of Scripture. To prevent misunderstandings, let's examine it in detail.

The Greek word translated “confess” means “to agree with, to acknowledge, to admit.” So this is not merely saying the words “Jesus is Lord,” but admitting this is true. And not just to yourself. He is talking about saying it out loud. In fact this is something a person would say before being baptized. They would confess before the whole congregation that they were acknowledging Jesus as the Lord. When we baptize someone even today, we ask them 6 questions. The first 3 are whether they renounce Satan, the evil powers in this world and the sinful desires that draw them away from God. The second three are “Do you turn to Jesus Christ and accept him as your Savior?”, “Do you put your whole trust in his grace and love?”, and “Do you promise to follow and obey him as your Lord?” The candidate for baptism answers each of these 3 questions with “I do.”

The point is that not merely are you saying these words but you are acknowledging Jesus is both the Lord and your Lord. In Paul's day that was dangerous. Because Lord was a title that Caesar took. As N.T. Wright points out, saying that Jesus is Lord means Caesar is not. As we said last week, that meant the emperors saw Jesus as a rival. And certain emperors required citizens to sacrifice to the Roman gods and denounce Jesus. Failure to comply could mean the loss of legal rights, being deprived of rank, being re-enslaved, being sent to work in the mines or even death. Confessing with your mouth that Jesus is Lord was considered treason.

And Kurios, the Greek word translated as Lord, meant two things. It meant Jesus was your master, whom you obeyed above all others. It also was the word used by Greek speaking Jews for God. To avoid using God's name in vain, Jews did not say God's actual name even when it appeared in scripture. Instead, they said Adonai, the Hebrew word for Lord. When the Hebrew Bible was translated into Greek, the Septuagint followed that practice, substituting Kurios for the divine name. You might call your teacher Master but when you used the title for Jesus, it meant something more. It meant that you gave Jesus your ultimate allegiance, something reserved for God.

But Paul knew that people can say things and not mean it. So he adds that you must also “believe in your heart...” The Greek word used here and throughout the New Testament for “believe” is pisteuo. It means more than simply believing that Jupiter has 95 officially recognized moons. Again that is largely irrelevant to the lives of anyone but astronomers. Pisteuo means to trust. If you really trust your doctor and he tells you to stop smoking or you will get cancer, emphysema or heart disease, you will do it. It took a massive heart attack to make my father-in-law change what he ate and take up exercise. As a nurse I saw a lot of patients who obviously did not believe their doctors and continued doing things that worked against their getting better. And we see people who call themselves Christians who obviously do not believe what Jesus said about what we are to do or not do as his followers.

Part of that might be that for them belief in Jesus doesn't seem particularly relevant to their life. They are comfortable. They have everything they want. They don't feel the need for anything more. All of that can change, however, when people find themselves at the end of their rope, when they are trapped in situations entirely outside of their control. Then, with nowhere else to turn, they have to figure out whether to put their trust in God or not. It can be hard. It can be scary. Joy Davidman came to such a point when her husband William Gresham called to tell her he was having a nervous breakdown and was not sure if he was coming home. Stuck at home with 2 small children she later wrote, “for the first time my pride was forced to admit that I was not, after all, 'the master of my fate'...All my defenses—all the walls of arrogance and cocksureness and self-love behind which I hid from God—went down momentarily—and God came in.” Eventually the marriage failed but her faith grew. Davidman discovered the writings of C.S. Lewis. She wrote to him, they became correspondents, and then friends and after a while, they married. Her death from cancer triggered a crisis of faith for Lewis which he chronicled in his most personal book, A Grief Observed.

People sometimes see faith as a crutch. As someone who regularly uses a cane and at times wheelchairs, I don't see a crutch as something to be ashamed of but simply as a matter of accepting the reality of the situation. Would it be better to fall or to crawl? In the disability community, dismissal of the accommodations we need is called ableism. It is also a failure to recognize that at any moment anyone can become disabled, through accident or disease. In fact, all of us will become disabled if we live long enough.

Faith in God is a recognition of the fact that we humans are not all-powerful or all-wise. We all need help. It is more obviously true when we are very young or very old, but no one is ever truly self-sufficient. Show me a successful person who was not either born well-off or helped at key times of their life and career by parents, grandparents, teachers, mentors, partners, or investors. Only the arrogant think they did it all by themselves. And arrogance, called pride in the Bible, is what C.S. Lewis called the ultimate anti-God state of mind. An arrogant person doesn't admit to needing anyone else, including God.

But faith needs an object. In what or in whom are you putting your trust? Paul writes in the verse we are examining, that you must “...believe in your heart that God raised him from the dead...” The resurrection is the reason that faith in Jesus as the Messiah went from the belief of a very small Jewish sect to a movement that spread all over the world. There have been many religious figures who said spiritually insightful things. There have been many people who claimed to be the Messiah or even God. They all died and stayed dead. And if Jesus was just another moral philosopher, you can take what he said or leave it. In fact, this is what the two disciples heading to Emmaus said about Jesus: “He was a prophet, powerful in word and deed before God and all the people. The chief priests and our rulers handed him over to be sentenced to death, and they crucified him; but we had hoped he was the one who was going to redeem Israel.” (Luke 24:20-21) And that wistful sentiment would have been the last word on Jesus—had he not defeated death.

Death is the last thing we face over which we have no control. A headline in the satirical website the Onion said, “Firefighter postpones 3 deaths.” Because, of course, when you save a life, you only save it temporarily. We all die. Even the rich and powerful. You may have seen the news story about the tech entrepreneur who was spending millions annually on extreme anti-aging and biohacking regimens only to be diagnosed with an incurable and progressive autoimmune disease. Even he wondered if he had “taken this whole longevity thing too far.” We are mortal. The disciples knew that. When Jesus died, they were grief-stricken but not surprised. When he left his tomb and appeared to them, letting them touch him and eating with them, they were stunned and even frightened. And then emboldened. Because now they knew a guy who conquered death. Most of the Twelve were martyred. None of them said that Jesus' resurrection was a hoax, even when doing so could have saved their lives. Charles Colson, Nixon's hatchet man turned Christian, points out that the most powerful men in America who got caught up in the Watergate scandal couldn't even stick to a lie when all they were facing was the loss of power and a few years of freedom, not the loss of their lives.

Michael Grant wrote that while as an historian he could not say that Jesus was raised from the dead, he did say that without the resurrection it was difficult to explain not merely the survival of Christianity but its phenomenal growth and spread. As N.T. Wright says that other followers of dead Messiahs either slink back to their previous quiet lives or latch on to the next Messiah wannabe. Instead, the disciples of Jesus went from cowering in an upper room for fear of the authorities doing to them what they did to Jesus, to boldly proclaiming him as the crucified and risen Messiah and Savior of the world. They defied the Sanhedrin, the very council that condemned Jesus, when told to stop their preaching. They went on to testify to their faith before kings and emperors. They lost their fear and gained salvation.

But salvation from what? If this life is the only one we get, they were fools for losing theirs. But not only did they trust that the man who conquered death would give them eternal life, they knew they needed to be saved from the slow death of whom they were created to be. We are all made in God's image, but we soon realize that this image in us has decayed. In some people it is barely perceptible. And we know that we are not mere animals, content to eat, survive long enough to mate and raise our offspring and then return to dust. We know we were made to do more, to fulfill our potential. But our thoughts, words and actions sabotage our lives and the lives of others. We do things we know we shouldn't and neglect things we know we should do. We know we fall short of who we should be. If we are honest, we admit we need help. Jesus can do that. Among his disciples was a man who worked as a tax collector for the occupation forces from Rome and another who was a member of a zealous Jewish political faction. He was buried in the tomb of a follower who had been a member of the Sanhedrin. His greatest missionary was a man who had been a fanatic Pharisee, devoted to arresting Jesus' followers. His church was made up of people who used to be sexually immoral, idol worshipers, thieves, drunkards, the verbally abusive, the greedy, and swindlers. (1 Corinthians 6:9-11) Jesus changed their lives. He saved them not only from eternal death but from their own sinful and spiritually deadly desires. He saved them from themselves.

It may not make much of a difference what you believe about the stars, but who you believe in and trust with your life is vital. Will you put that trust in technology? Or in your flawed unaided self? Or in other fallible people? Or will you put your trust in the person who said “I am the resurrection and the life,” and then proved it by getting up from his grave and appearing to his frightened followers, scarred but healthy and no longer subject to what we assumed were the laws of biology and physics? Encountering the risen Jesus changed the men and women who had lived with him for 3 ½ years and through them he changed the world as no one has before or since.

Jesus said, “I am the way, the truth and the life.” He also said, “I and my Father are one.” C.S. Lewis pointed out that he was either right or wrong about that. If he was wrong, he was either a lunatic—someone who could not reliably operate in reality—or a liar, someone who was pulling a scam for money or power or sex. You may have met someone who was psychotic and delusional. You have certainly met someone who tells grandiose lies about himself. Does Jesus strike you as either? If not, then the only alternative is that Jesus is right and that he is the Lord. Then ask yourself this: if the God who created this marvelous world were to become one of us, wouldn't we expect him to be like Jesus: just but loving and healing and forgiving and willing to do anything to save the creatures he made in his image? What or who is the truth you are willing to trust?

You Give Them Something

The scriptures referred to are Matthew 14:13-21.

One reason that the writers of the Constitution put the separation of church and state in the first amendment was because they understood the role religion invariably came to play when united to the government: it simply blessed the status quo. Kings were either gods, the offspring of gods or the representatives of the chief god. It's easier to get the people behind you if you portray your actions as the will of the gods, rather than your personal will. Folks aren't as likely to die to expand the nation's territory merely because the leader wants to rule it for egotistical reasons. So they say that the people whose country they are planning on invading are evil or heretics and thus they are going to war because, as they said in the crusades, “God wills it!”

Weirdly, there are Christians who think that their religion should function as an arm of the government, rather than be independent of it. Which means they really don't read the Bible. While there were schools of prophets who were sponsored by the king (1 Kings 22:6), almost all of the prophets included in the Bible were critics of those in power. Jeremiah was a thorn in the side of a number of kings. (e.g. Jeremiah 36:1-26) Hosea railed against the godless kings of Israel. (Hosea 7:3-7) Amos denounced the corruption in both Israel and Judah. (Amos 2:4-8) Again and again they remind God's people that there is a higher authority than any mere human ruler, the best of whom are imperfect and will someday die. God is the ultimate judge and king over all the earth. To forget that is to invite disaster.

There is another problem with seeing the nation's political leader as also being the nation's religious leader. It shifts the responsibility to maintain our relationship with God to that person. Julius Caesar held the office of pontifex maximus, the chief priest of the Roman state. It was a position held for life. And it had tremendous religious and political influence. Beginning with his son Augustus, it became a title automatically given to the emperors. Eventually they were also considered living gods. One of the problems they had with Christianity was that Christians called Jesus the “only Son of God” as well as “King of kings and Lord of lords.” That made Jesus and the emperor rivals.

Basically the pontifex maximus was responsible for seeing that all the religious festivals were observed and all rituals were carried out properly to appease the gods, so that they would favor the Roman empire. And Roman religion was primarily about rituals, not faith or caring about other people. The relationship with the gods was contractual. The basic principle was “I give that you might give.” You made a sacrifice to the gods, said the proper prayers and rituals and you expected a quid pro quo from them.

Unfortunately, a lot of people today also think that if they go to church, say the prayers and do the rituals, that's all that is required for them to be good with God. They think that religion is something that takes place in a special building for about an hour on Sunday. In the film Don Jon, Joseph Gordon-Levitt's character says, “There's only a few things I really care about in life. My pad. My ride. My family. My church. My boys. My girls. And my porn.” He's a single young man who lives however he wants the rest of the week as long as he goes to confession on Saturday, Mass on Sunday and then dinner with his large family. And he sees no contradiction in that. If you transplanted him to ancient Rome, he'd be right at home as a pagan.

In ancient religions, you didn't look to the gods to see how you should behave because the gods did not behave any better than humans do. Ancient mythologies would be a great deal shorter if you eliminated all the times Zeus couldn't keep it in his pants, or Loki wasn't pulling a scam, or the gods weren't warring with one another. A lot of myths say the earth was created from the body parts of a god or goddess killed by a different god. The gods were superior to human beings only in terms of their power, not their morality. They were like superheroes but without ethical qualities like honesty, faithfulness, or selflessness. You worshiped them not because they cared about you but because if you didn't, they could make your life miserable.

The gospel or good news of Jesus Christ caught on because it says that God loves us, so much so that his son became one of us and even died to save us. Then he rose to give us eternal life. Despite what some misinformed YouTubers say, no other god did that. Gods who died stayed dead, like Balder and in fact, all the Norse gods at Ragnarok. Osiris' wife did reassemble his dismembered body to impregnate herself but that was temporary. He went back to being dead and ruling the underworld. There is a passage in the Poetic Edda where Odin speaks of hanging on the world tree for 9 days but he did not die. And he did not do this to pay for anyone's sins but to learn for himself the magical secrets of the runes.

In contrast, in Jesus we see what God is really like: just, loving, and forgiving. He is the very image of God. (Hebrews 1:3) And in Jesus we also see what we can become, because we were created in the image of God but marred it by misusing his gifts to harm ourselves, others and our relationship with God. By trusting and uniting ourselves to Jesus, he will restore the image of God in us.

But it doesn't happen simply by doing rituals or saying certain prayers and then passively waiting for some magical transformation. It involves us serving Christ in our everyday life. We are called by Jesus to be his disciples, which is just another word for students. When I studied to be a nurse, most nursing schools were attached to hospitals. So we spent half the day in the classroom, getting the necessary medical knowledge, and half the day in the hospital, putting what we learned into practice. It bothers me that nursing is becoming more academic, not because there isn't so much more to learn—there is—but because modern nursing students spend most of their time in classrooms, especially if they are getting a Bachelor's degree in nursing, which is becoming the minimum qualification to become an RN in many states. In that case, it is a major they take along with other classes. At the end of each period in which they are studying a certain specialty, like psychiatry, obstetrics, or orthopedics, they spend a week or two shadowing working nurses at a hospital or a nursing home. As an LPN I found myself showing newly graduated nurses, soon to be BSNs, how to do certain basic procedures. They had a lot of textbook learning and managerial theory but very little practical experience doing hands-on nursing.

In contrast, Jesus sent out the Twelve, and later 72 other disciples, to get experience by preaching and healing. (Luke 10:1) He said, “As you go, preach this message: 'The kingdom of heaven is near!' Heal the sick, raise the dead, cleanse lepers, cast out demons. Freely have you received, freely give.” (Matthew 10:7) In other words, do what you've seen me doing. That's the way to become more Christlike.

Today's gospel passage comes after the disciples returned from their mission. The feeding of the 5000 is the only miracle recorded in all 4 Gospels. (Matthew 14:15-21; Mark 6:35-44; Luke 9:12-17; John 6:4-13) Obviously it made a big impact. But the part that I want to draw attention to is in verses 15 and 16 of our passage. We read, “When it was evening, the disciples came to him and said, 'This is a deserted place, and the hour is now late; send the crowds away so that they may go into the villages and buy food for themselves.' Jesus said to them, 'They need not go away; you give them something to eat.'”

The disciples balk at this, citing the fact that they don't have enough food. So Jesus takes over. But I don't think that Jesus just said this so that they would refuse and he could show how powerful he was. He probably foresaw what would happen afterwards—the people he fed would want to make him a king. (John 6:15) And they did not know just what kind of king Jesus was called to be. So he had to dissuade them by emphasizing how he would feed them spiritually through his body and blood. (John 6:25-69)

I think he really meant that the disciples should give the people something to eat. After all, they knew the stories of how Elijah and Elisha multiplied food (1 Kings 17:14-16; 2 Kings 4:42-44) And Jesus had given them the power to heal the sick and raise the dead. What was feeding 5000 people next to that?

But they didn't think of doing that. They left it to Jesus. He was their leader. Let him handle that. And he could and did. But it let them off the hook.

And I'm afraid a lot of Christians feel that because of what Jesus did on the cross, they merely have to say, “I believe,” and then sit back until he returns. But being a Christian is not a static state; it is a learning process. It's more than just sticking your nose in a book, even if it's the Good Book. It's applying what you learn there to the real life situations you find yourself in. Is it scary? Yes. Do you sometimes feel inadequate? Yes. I can remember the first time I did certain procedures on a patient, afraid I would botch it and hurt them. But they survived and I got experience and I got better at caring for and helping others. And a lot of Christianity is caring for and helping others by not only telling them the good news but being the good news to them. As someone said, “Preach the gospel always and when necessary, use words.”

Anthropologists say there are three elements of religion: beliefs, behaviors and belonging. Many Christians tend to focus primarily on beliefs. Some Christians are more concerned with belonging to their particular denomination. But what has hurt us the most in the world is our attitude towards behaviors. For instance, we spend a lot of time thinking and talking about sexual issues, especially when it comes to what others do. That's something Skye Jethani calls “crotch Christianity.” Yet only 9% of all the commandments in the Bible are about sex. Whereas there are more than 800 verses in the Bible about our duties to the poor, the hungry, the fatherless, the widowed, the sick, the disabled, and the resident alien. Not only do a lot of Christians neglect those, some say that giving such things a high priority is wrong. Russell Moore relates how many pastors have told him that after preaching on the Sermon on the Mount, their congregants asked them where they got such woke talking points. And when the pastors tell them this is what Jesus said, the reply is that those things are weak and don't apply anymore. Yet when speaking about the criteria on which he will judge us in the end, Jesus says it is what we do or don't do to those who are destitute, diseased, imprisoned or immigrants. (Matthew 25:31-46) Neglecting them is the same as neglecting Jesus.

Don't misunderstand me. I am not saying that the church alone should or can handle every possible need. Unlike in Jesus' day we don't have an emperor who is pontifex maximus nor a god. We have a government of the people, by the people and for the people. The healthiest and most stable nations today provide a safety net for the needy and seek to help everyone in the country not only survive but thrive. Nor are these communist nations. Finland and the Scandinavian countries consistently come out on top in quality of life and happiness. It's a matter of priorities as to how to use what we have as a nation. Do we simply let a few take as much as they can or do we use what we all have produced to make things better for everyone?

The twelve disciples saw a bunch of hungry people and told Jesus to send them away to take care of it themselves. In reply, he told the disciples, “You give them something to eat.” We see a world full of people who are suffering from lack of food, water, shelter, justice, healthcare, and love. We go to God in prayer and tell him to take care of them. But after we stop talking to him, if we then listen to him, we will find him saying, “You give them something. Freely have you received, freely give.”