Sunday, July 14, 2024

The Big Picture

The scriptures referred to are Ephesians 1:3-14.

On our recent trip to the northwest, my son, my daughter and I got along great. Except for one thing. They like to use Google maps for navigation whereas I like Waze. Each has advantages the other doesn't, though these are becoming less obvious since Google bought Waze in 2013 for $1.3 billion. Which to my mind shows how much that they considered Waze to be the superior app. Regardless, I also bought along the latest Rand-McNally road atlas. And everytime we entered a national park, I picked up a map of the park. Why? Because while the navigation apps are fine for taking you to a destination, your view is just the road you're on and about 1000 yards ahead, and maybe a few hundred feet on either side. What you don't get is the big picture. You don't see the whole trip at once nor any of the other features around you. You don't see how everything connects.

One of the great things about this trip was seeing something you can't see in Florida: mountains! We saw dun-colored mountains dotted with scrub like in the old Western movies. We saw green mountains covered with tall pine trees all the way up to the summit. We saw raw black and grey stone mountains, some with snow-capped peaks. We drove up the switchback roads that took us up the mountains so that the person on the right side of the car could look down and see the sheer drop of thousands of feet. It was scary! At overlooks we got out and gazed at awesome vistas with rivers in the valleys, or sometimes lakes, and blue mountains rising into the clouds on the other side. We saw waterfalls and we scattered my mom's ashes just above one. The view from the mountains was breathtaking. You could see the whole landscape.

In our reading from Ephesians, the apostle Paul gives us a magnificent overview of what God is doing for us. Some scholars say that the passage doesn't sound like Paul. True, it doesn't sound like one of his typical closely reasoned rabbinic arguments such as we see in Romans. But given the nature of what Paul is saying and how he is saying it, it is not surprising. In the original Greek this passage is one long compound sentence. Most translations break it up into shorter sentences to make it more easily read and understood. But there is a poetic, cascading quality to it. And Paul could get poetic at times, as in 1 Corinthians 13, the chapter on Christian love. So to make sure we don't miss a single feature of this scenic drive through God's purpose for us, we are going to stop after each leg of the journey and take in the view.

“Blessed be the God and Father of our Lord Jesus Christ, who has blessed us in Christ with every spiritual blessing found in the heavenly places...” Notice that the word “bless” in some form appears 3 times in this opening. That's our theme: all the ways that God blesses us.

First, says Paul, God chose us. That's amazing. Out of all the humans on the planet, God chooses us. Moreover, he chose us “before the foundation of the world.” So he also picked us out of all the humans in history. Now this bothers some people. If God chooses people even before they exist, before, in fact, anyone existed, isn't that blatant favoritism? No. Because unlike humans, God doesn't choose on the basis of beauty or brains or even perfect behavior. (1 Samuel 16:7) Just look at the people the Bible tells us God did choose: Abraham, a coward when it comes to defending his wife's honor (Genesis 12:10-20); Jacob, a man who cons his brother out of his birthright and his father out of his brother's blessing (Genesis 25:29-34; 27:1-38); Joseph, a rather egotistical and undiplomatic boy (Genesis 37:5-11); Moses, a hothead who hates public speaking (Exodus 2:11-12; 4:10-16); David, a womanizer who uses his power ro eliminate his lover's husband (2 Samuel 11 and 12); and Peter, an impulsive and sometimes fickle follower (Matthew 26:31-75).

So why did God choose them? First of all, we are all sinners, so it's not like he had a group of perfect people to choose from. And secondly, it's because they ultimately say “Yes” to God and do his will. Remember Jesus' parable of the 2 brothers asked by their father to do their chores. One says, “Yes,” but doesn't follow that up with any action. The other says, “No,” but reconsiders and obeys his father. (Matthew 21:28-32) “Reconsider” is actually a possible translation for the Greek word used for “repent.” God doesn't choose the perfect; he picks those humble enough that they are willing to reconsider that they might be wrong and therefore change the direction of their lives.

But if God chooses us before time, isn't that predestination? Yes, and many people are bothered by how arbitrary that seems. Yet we do not have any incidents where God chooses someone who does not fulfill his function. It's like the all-knowing God knows whom to choose! And indeed in his letter to the Romans Paul says, “Because whom he foreknew, he also predestined to be conformed to the image of his Son...” (Romans 8:29) While some theologians see it differently, the most fair interpretation is that God chooses those whom he knows beforehand will respond to his grace. Any other interpretation makes the preaching of the gospel unnecessary since such folks would inevitably be saved anyway (Romans 10:14) and it makes any response that we make to the gospel, such as repentance and faith, mere puppetry on God's part. If we don't have some scintilla of free will, then we are not responsible for the evil we do.

Those who disagree think that God is somehow diminished if he is not in control of everything, including our response. Nothing, they say, can limit God or make him do anything. Except that God can. He can deliberately limit himself to allow us a space in which to exercise some free will. This is like a parent allowing a small child the chance to do something for himself at times, though the parent could do it better. But the child will never grow up if he is not allowed to choose his own clothes, or do his own homework. God is not a helicopter parent, hovering over us, removing all obstacles from our path. After my accident, the physical therapists helped me relearn to walk but they did not move my legs for me. Otherwise I would never be able to walk on my own.

Nor does God's knowing beforehand what we will do determine what we will do. If I can predict quite accurately how my grandchild will react if I give her a gift that is her heart's desire, it's not strictly accurate to say I am causing her to jump up and down and squeal. My knowledge of what she will do is based on what I know about her. My knowing doesn't force her to do it, nor does my acting on that knowledge. She could calmly say, “Thank you, grandfather.” But she won't because of who she is, not because of what I know her to be. God's knowing how we will respond to his love and grace doesn't mean he is forcing us to respond that way. He just knows us so well he knows how we will act.

But all of this is really beside the point that Paul is making. He is praising God for the blessing of having chosen us. He doesn't intend us to get into a philosophical debate but to join him in being thankful. Our blessing is secure because it is God who chooses us.

And he chooses us “to be holy and blameless before him in love.” “Holy” doesn't mean “self-righteous” but rather “set apart” for a purpose. The Greek word for “blameless” is more literally “without blemish.” It is the word used of an animal fit to be an offering to God. God chose us to become holy and blameless for his purpose. And his purpose is a loving one.

In addition, God has “predestined us to adoption through Jesus Christ.” God chose us to become adopted members of his family, another blessing. Adoption means a real change in status. When Caesar Augustus adopted his wife's son by a previous marriage, Tiberius became his full heir and his successor as emperor. Adoption makes one a full-fledged member of God's family. God adopts us as his children through Jesus Christ, his uniquely begotten Son who made this possible. There is nothing precarious or second class about our position as members of God's family.

God did this “in accordance with the good pleasure of his will.” Some variation of this phrase appears 4 times in our reading. N.T. Wright translates it this way: “That's how he wanted it and that's what gave him delight.” Some think of God as remote. But this says he granted us membership in his family, not out of necessity or out of any feeling of obligation, but because it delighted him. God wanted to raise us to the status of full members of his family and it pleased him to do so. This is grace, God's undeserved and unreserved goodness towards us.

“In him we have redemption through his blood...” Our adoption did have a price. “Redemption” literally means being bought back. In Biblical times, people sometimes got so deep in debt that they would sell themselves into slavery to pay it off. If this unfortunate person had a wealthy and willing relative, he might be redeemed or bought back from slavery and made free again. It meant paying off what the person owed. And that could be pricey. In our case, the price of our freedom was the blood of the Beloved.

This brings us to “the forgiveness of our trespasses,” or sins. There really isn't any other way to deal with sins. You can't undo them. You can't untell the lie, unwreck the car, unabuse the child, or unkill the victim. These things can only be forgiven. And since everything comes from God, ultimately the person we sin against in every instance is him. The human being we harmed was his person, made in his image. And as we say in the Lord's Prayer, if we expect God to forgive us for our sins, we must also forgive those who sin against us.

“With all wisdom and insight, he has made known to us the mystery of his will...” Our next blessing is that God has not left us in the dark but he has let us know his plan, “the mystery of his will.” What is the answer to this mystery of life? It is that God intends to unify and to bring to maturity all of creation in Jesus Christ. Just as we suspect, things are not what they should be. Left to themselves all things fall apart. That's true of us as well. But God's plan is to put us back together and to put everything right, in and through his Son. The world is not like a ship going down and God's plan is not to simply rescue his people from the ship and take them to heaven. Instead the world is like a mansion he has given us which we have neglected and even vandalized. God plans to do an extreme makeover and he is recruiting us, the vandals, to work with him in repairing and restoring it. Jesus is the blueprint. In him we see how we, the body of Christ, can work together, each of us using our God-given gifts, to stop the damage, repair it and make it good as new. (Ephesians 2:19-22) In the fullness of time, God intends us to live in it, the new heavens and new earth, with him. (Revelation 21:3)

That's our inheritance. As children of God, all that is his is ours. (Revelation 21:7) This world, restored through Christ, is to be ours. It is the inheritance of the meek, those who are humble before God, not of the arrogant as it seems to be today. (Matthew 5:5) We are those who “set our hope on Christ.” We have heard the gospel, the good news, and “believed in him.” Note that our belief is not in a system or a party or a nation or an idea, but in a person, and not in a pastor or a secular leader, but Jesus alone. And so God has marked us “with the seal of the promised Holy Spirit.” This image of sealing that Paul uses comes from the practice of marking anything sent out—a bag, a package, a jar—with the seal of its owner. His signet ring was pressed into hot wax, leaving an impression with his image, name and titles. It signified ownership and, if unbroken, it guaranteed security. God has sealed us, put his stamp on us, with his Spirit. And his Spirit is also “the pledge of our inheritance,” both a foretaste of it and a down payment.

This is a much neglected teaching in the church today. We have a very poor idea of the importance and work of the Spirit. When we come to God, we are not joining a club. We are not free agents choosing to affiliate with God. It is more like entering rehab or boot camp. What we are doing is as much internal as external. Remaking creation means being remade ourselves by God's Spirit within us.

In the classic film The Lilies of the Field, Sidney Poitier plays an ex-G.I. named Homer Smith. He's a handyman whose car breaks down in the desert in Arizona. There he encounters a group of East German nuns, who escaped communism and are setting up a mission for Mexican Americans. Smith is hired to do small jobs but eventually is convinced to build them a chapel. It's not easy because both Smith and the Mother Superior are strong-willed. But during the building of the chapel, both are changed. So, too, are we changed during our work together to restore God's creation. But it is not left to chance, nor do we do this in our own strength. It is the work of the Spirit. The Spirit guides us to be the change we are endeavoring to make in this world. And this change, seen in the development of the fruit of the Spirit, is our foretaste of the world to come. (Galatians 5:22-23)

That's the big picture, a glimpse from the mountain top of what God is doing and how he is blessing us. God chooses us for his purposes, buying us out of slavery to our sins, adopting us as his children, revealing his plan to transform everything through Jesus Christ into what it is meant to become and giving us his Spirit as a foretaste of our inheritance.

And the place of churches and communities of Christ in God's plan are not places in which to escape this world but instead, supply stations, where we come to receive what we need for our part in God's plan. To take a metaphor from my daughter's former career as a long distance truck driver, a church is like a spiritual truck stop. It is a place to pause and get refreshment, to get clean, to get some rest, to get nourishment and to get fueled up. It is not the end of the journey. Its purpose is to give you what you need for the next leg of your journey with Jesus. And everyone in the church is involved in that. Truckers bring what they have and know and share it with each other: “This is a good route,” “Here is a good supplier,” “This is a reliable contact,” “Here's a helpful trick I've picked up in my work,” “Sure, I'll pass on your message,” “I'll keep you in mind as I travel.” And we are to do the same for each other. The more we bring to our gathering and the more we share, the more we come away with.

In a while it will be time for us gathered here to head back out into the world. It will be time to take what we have received here and apply it to whatever tasks God has set before us. We can't stay in the church service forever. But in the meantime there is plenty to savor. Soon we will join God for a cup to drink and some bread to eat, a foretaste of the heavenly banquet to come. We will need to get cleaned up through confession and forgiveness. And we will recite a classic statement of the big picture.

It's a big world out there and a big task we have before us. But never forget: we have been blessed with a big God and he is with us every step of the way, right here, in our hearts and in our minds and in our lives.

First preached on July 12, 2009. It has been updated and revised.

Sunday, July 7, 2024

What We Need

We used to think that the earth was the center of the universe. The planets and even the sun were thought to orbit the earth. Contrary to popular belief, this idea did not come from the Bible but from ancient Greek philosophers like Ptolemy and Aristotle. Things didn't change until 1543 when Copernicus, a Catholic priest, proposed a heliocentric or sun-centered arrangement of our solar system. And Galileo confirmed it by telescope in 1610. So we are no longer at the center of the universe in science's consideration. Or are we?

In 1973, at a symposium commemorating the 500th birthday of Copernicus, theoretical physicist Brandon Carter coined the term “anthropic principle” to refer to the fact that many of the features of our universe, such as its age, the gravitational constant, the mass of the proton, and others, are precisely those needed to allow life to develop. If their values were greater or less than they are, life could not exist anywhere. And this fact makes some scientists, especially atheistic ones, uncomfortable because it looks as if our universe is, if not designed, then at least fine-tuned to promote the development of life. To avoid that, they have proposed that there are multiple universes with different conditions in them and this just happens to be the one which permits life to exist. Other scientists point out that there is no evidence of these alternate universes (Sorry, MCU) and that this is just an excuse not to contemplate the implications of a universe that is apparently built around life.

Our sermon suggestion question is “Did we create God just to make ourselves feel better and explain away the mysteries?” In other words, is God, as an acquaintance of mine puts it, just an imaginary friend for adults?

It's an appealing way to explain away a God you don't wish to exist. Desiring that there is a God doesn't make it true, anymore than desiring ice cream means that when you open your freezer, you'll find it packed with Ben and Jerry's. But as the anthropic principle shows, that while it may not grant our desires, reality does conform to our needs. C.S. Lewis pointed out that, for instance, our appetite for food is strong evidence that food does exist, if not in your fridge then somewhere in the world. Your body really does need it.

And not all of our needs are physical. Love and affection are real needs for human beings. You may have heard of the horrific findings of a study of Romanian orphanages. Even when all of their physical needs were taken care of, children who did not receive love and attention from the overworked staff often died. Those who survived were mentally damaged. The question is not, then, do we desire God but do we need God?

How do we define needs? One element is that a need is natural whereas a desire can be created. We need food to live but we only desire Doritos or Dr. Pepper or blooming onions because media, marketing, and even our peers brainwash us into thinking we must have them. So is there any evidence that belief in God comes from within people or is it urged upon us from without?

As it turns out, a study by Oxford researchers shows that children naturally believe that there is a God who designed the world. This is true even in cultures, such as the Japanese, in which kids are not indoctrinated with religious beliefs. The evidence is so overwhelming that the senior researcher, anthropologist Dr. Justin Barrett, said of children, “If we threw a handful on an island and they raised themselves, I think they would believe in God.” This is not proof that God exists but certainly it is evidence that God is not an unnatural concept inflicted on us by others for either well-intentioned or nefarious reasons. In fact, comedian Julia Sweeney, an atheist, was dismayed to find that her daughter believed in God, though not raised to do so. Studies show it is hard to convince kids otherwise, at least until they get to be 12.

And every day the evidence mounts that our brains, if not hardwired for belief in God, are at least God-friendly in the same sense that the universe is life-friendly. While there has been a lot of attention to the growing group of “nones,” people who do not have a religious affiliation, the vast majority are neither atheists or agnostics. 70% of people who say they don't have a religion believe in God. This should not surprise anyone. If you are a believer, then you would expect belief in God to be a sort of default setting. If you are a non-believer, then everything must be explained without resorting to the supernatural and that means the widespread belief in God has to arise naturally.

Still like the anthropic principle, the implications of the naturalness of belief in God discomforts atheists. They would much prefer that the explanation for belief in God be that it is an aberration or a socially transmitted delusion. Because, according to them, the effects of religious belief are overwhelmingly negative. But is that true?

A study by the Paris School of Economics and the European Center for Social Welfare Policy and Research shows that religious people are more content and cope better with life's shocks, such as the death of a loved one or the loss of a job. After more than a decade of studying the relationship between religious belief and health, University of Miami researcher Michael McCullough says that, by a wide margin, religious people do better in school, live longer, have more satisfying marriages, and are generally happier than nonbelievers. They have better self-control and are less likely to break the law, have sex outside marriage, do drugs or abuse alcohol. Obviously there are exceptions but these positive effects are true of the majority of people who believe in God.

Ok, so believing in God can make your life better, but is that the same as a need? Remember the unloved Romanian orphans? Not all died, but those who lived had serious psychological impairments. So one could argue that God is a need in the same sense that love is, or that certain vitamins are. You won't necessarily die if you don't get enough Vitamin D but your life will be less healthy and probably not as long. Certainly a lot of the behaviors that religious people tend to avoid, like drinking or breaking the law, will, if indulged in, lead to a less healthy and probably shortened life.

But we are talking about social behaviors here. Does belief in God have actual physical benefits? McCollough has found a positive correlation between church attendance (the only objective way for scientists to measure religiosity) and lower incidence of blood pressure and of heart disease, the number one cause of death in this country. A study in the Journal of Health and Social Behavior shows religious people have a lower mortality rate from digestive and respiratory cancer. Believers spend less time in hospitals and recover faster. Levels of interleukin-6, which indicate immune response, are elevated in conditions such as AIDS, osteoporosis, Alzheimer's, diabetes, and other diseases. A 6-year study of more than 1700 older adults found that those who regularly attend religious services tend to have lower interleukin-6 levels, which might explain the overall better health and better recovery rates of believers.

Can not believing kill you? It can make you more likely to kill yourself. Suicide rates are much lower among actively religious people, a fact attributed to stronger moral objections to suicide and lower levels of aggression. Believers also have significantly lower degrees of hopelessness, which is described in a 1998 study as “the most critical psychological variable predictive of suicidal ideation and behavior.” In fact, according to the World Health Organization, “Of the top ten nations with the highest male suicide rates, all but one (Sri Lanka) are strongly irreligious nations with high levels of atheism...of the bottom ten nations with the lowest male suicide rates, all are highly religious nations with statistically insignificant levels of organic atheism.” (In the US the suicide rate among males is 4 times higher than among females. It is the second most common cause of death for men under the age of 45.) Of course, many irreligious nations have legalized suicide and assisted suicide. It is also interesting to note that Sri Lanka, the one religious country among the top ten countries with a high male suicide rate, was also the site of a recently resolved but decades-long civil war, in which the Tamal Tigers, atheistic Marxists, pioneered the technique of suicide bombing! That may have influenced that country's data on male suicides.

So there are personal benefits to believing in God. But does that personal belief translate into social good? Again Michael McCollough, by having folks remember past wrongs while monitoring their anger and stress through their heart rate, blood pressure and perspiration, found that religious people are less vengeful and more forgiving. And throughout the history of the world, hospitals, schools, orphanages, and charities have been primarily founded by religious organizations. This creates a culture in which these things come to be considered so important that eventually they are adopted and supported by governments and social entities. In fact, historian Tom Holland has shown that the values we take for granted—compassion for the unfortunate, helping the disadvantaged, caring for the sick, rooting for the underdog—are all due to the influence of Christianity upon our culture. They were not the norm before the spread of belief in Jesus, the God who is love. Studies have shown that religion is the key factor in building civilizations, because it binds large numbers of strangers with beliefs, behaviors and a sense of belonging that otherwise would not exist outside of a family or tribe.

Sociologist Rodney Stark argued that science arose in the Christian West due to a belief in a single rational God who created human beings in his image. This meant humans could understand the mind of God through exploring his creation. Other great civilizations like China, though they had a head start on the West in the sciences, did not continue to build on them because they believed in multiple gods who often warred with one another or who had control of only certain aspects of creation.

So is God a need? Belief in God is natural; it spontaneously arises in children; it is present in virtually every culture; and it is in complete harmony with the way our brains are set up. Belief in God is good for both the physical and mental health of the individual and it is beneficial to society at large. But what about the idea that religion mostly causes negative effects on society, like wars? Researcher Michael White, who catalogued the 100 biggest atrocities in history, has found that only 10% of wars were caused by religion. 90% of wars had nonreligious causes. And let us not forget that the officially atheistic nations of the Soviet Union and the People's Republic of China killed 100 times more people in just one century than did so-called “Christians” in 20 centuries. Because the greater violence we see in atheistic societies might be due to the fact that when you remove God as the supreme authority, you create a power vacuum. In steps the next highest authority, the State. And no State ever said, “love your enemies.”

It certainly looks like God is a need for healthy individuals and healthy societies. But does that mean God exists? I mean, maybe we created God to fill that need. If so, this would make it the only need ever to arise without a reality to fill it. It would be like having a stomach in a world without food. If it's a need, going without a way to fill that need is harmful. The answer to a need needs to exist. You need shelter; shelter exists. You need sleep; sleep exists. You need love; love exists. You need God but God doesn't? How could that possibly be?

It's even nonsense from an evolutionary point of view. According to Darwin, things change in order to better adapt to an environment. This means that an animal that lives in a tree evolves feet or paws or claws that conform better to the reality of tree trunks and branches. To create a sense of a God who isn't there means to evolve in response to an unreality. It would be like an animal that lives in the desert evolving fins or gills.

Ah, but could God be a mistaken answer to a need for something else? But what would that be? What else encompasses all the needs that God fills? God gives us meaning. God gives us a moral code. God forgives our sins, God gives us love. God gives us someone to pray to. God gives us someone to emulate. God gives us lots to think about. God gives us much to sing about. God gives us a promise of justice. God gives us a reason to hope. God pushes us to expand our ideas of what we can do, of who is a member of our family, of how we are to respond to injustice and to the needs of others. There is no one thing that does all that. People have tried to substitute other things for God—the state, the family, other groups, friendship, romance, art, entertainment, sports, celebrity worship, other cultural phenomena—but none is adequate. Trying to use them in place of God is like pica—the compulsion to eat dirt or other inedible substances, displayed by some pregnant women, in response to a lack of certain necessary minerals in their diet. Nobody prefers dirt to a good diet, the thing you really need.

There is no substitute for God and no getting around the fact that we need him. This is not to say that people don't try to recreate God in an image more to their liking. People try to eliminate his more fearsome aspects to make him more cuddly, thereby declawing his moral force. Others try to eliminate his unconditional love for all his creatures in order to make him more partisan. Some elevate a charismatic human leader, like Hitler or a cult leader, to godlike status, only to see him fall when his hubris makes him go too far. Some reduce God to an abstract concept that underlies the universe but which will not interfere with how we choose to live our lives. Some reduce him to a hanging judge and others to an abusive father and still others to an ineffectual but well-meaning grandfather. But the real God defies being pigeonholed.

When Moses asked his name, God replied, “I am who I am.” Which doesn't tell us a lot. It's almost as if God were saying, “I exist and that's all you need to know for now.” In Jesus Christ, we get a clearer picture of the God who made us and loves us and redeemed us. But we still don't know everything about him. We never will. A God who is totally comprehensible to the human mind is not the God who made everything. And that speaks to other needs he fills—the needs for wonder and for curiosity and to ponder and to explore. We need them as we need God. And we need to remember how much more there is to life, the universe and everything than simply what we see.

First preached on July 5, 2009. It has been updated.

Saturday, July 6, 2024

Button and String

It was a rainy Sunday morning and the little girl was stuck at Grandma's house. Grandma didn't have cable or streaming or a DVD player and she didn't have video games. And she wouldn't let the girl use her Grandma's phone. If you told her you were bored, she'd say, “Go read a book.” Grandma had lots of books but they didn't have pictures, so the girl wasn't interested. And worst of all, Grandma made her go to church.

She hated church. People read stories that she didn't understand and they ate this bread that didn't taste like anything and drank this wine that was bitter. So that morning Grandma got her up early and made her breakfast—the breakfast was good; in fact, eating was the best thing about visiting Grandma. She made the girl get dressed—she had made her take a bath the night before; that was one of the worst things about visiting Grandma—and she fussed over the girl's hair. Then Grandma went to get dressed. And there being nothing good on the few channels Grandma's TV got, the girl went into Grandma's bedroom.

Grandma was in her bathroom with the door closed. The girl heard the hissing sound of a spray can and got a whiff of that stuff she sprayed on her hair. The girl was glad the door was closed because that stuff made it so you couldn't breathe. The girl sat at the little desk that Grandma called a vanity and started going through the drawers. That's how she found the jewelry box. In it were rings and necklaces and earrings. Some were made of silver, some of gold; some were plain and some ornamented; some contained stones: opals, amethysts, blue-fired diamonds. Within the jewelry box, she found a smaller box, covered with velvet. She popped it open to find an old button with a small loop of string through it. She looked for a ring or something else of value but there was nothing more in the tiny box. Just then Grandma came out of the bathroom.

Puzzled, the girl held up her discovery and said, “Grandma, what's this?”

The woman turned and looked at the button and string in the girl's hand and said, “Where did you find that?”

“In your jewelry box,” the girl said, a bit sheepishly. “It was in a little box.”

The Grandmother took the button with the string and a look crossed her face that the girl couldn't read. The woman sat on the side of the bed and stared at the button. There was a long silence that the girl sensed she must not interrupt. Finally her grandmother spoke.

“A long time ago, when I was a girl, my friends from work and I went to a dance. There was a war going on then and there were soldiers there. Boys, really, not much older than ourselves. My friends and I stood around talking about the young men in their uniforms and giggling. There was one boy who...I don't know...I just liked the look of him. I saw him but I wasn't sure if he saw me. I wanted to talk to him but I didn't know how. He went up to the refreshments table so I hurried over there, trying to look like I wasn't hurrying. There was a double line and I got into the one next to him. I wanted to say something but I didn't know what. I hoped he'd say something or look at me and smile or even sneeze so I could say, “God bless you.” Or anything. But he seemed preoccupied and looked straight ahead. We got to the head of the line and I knew it was now or never but I still didn't know what to say. Then he reached for a cup of punch and I saw it.

“'You're going to lose that button,' I said.

“'Huh?' he said. He looked down his uniform shirt and then at me.

“'On your cuff,' I said, pointing. 'The button's coming loose.'

“”He lifted his wrist to look, careful not to spill his punch. 'Oh, yeah. Thanks,' he said.

“'I could sew it on for you,' I said.

“'Okay,' he said. And he smiled. So we went to some chairs and I pulled a little sewing kit out of my purse and as I sewed the button back on, we talked. We talked about the music and our favorite songs and we talked about our favorite movies and we talked about our favorite books. And when I finished sewing the button onto his sleeve, I buttoned the cuff. And he turned his hand over to look at it and at the same time he took my hand. I don't know if he noticed it but I noticed it. We continued to talk and hold hands. And when the dance was over, we walked and talked into the night.

“We passed a bank and I looked up and saw this big clock. It was after midnight. And I said, 'Oh, my God! My father will kill me! He'll never let me see you again.'

“He suddenly looked alarmed and said, 'I must see you again. Because tomorrow at 0700 hours, I gotta be back on base. I'm shipping out at 0900!'

“I started to cry because I realized I really might not ever see him again. He put his arm around me and comforted me and calmed me down and then we talked some more. We made a decision and he walked me home. Luckily, my parents were asleep.”

The grandmother stopped and looked at her granddaughter. Was she setting a bad example when it came to obeying her parents? But what she had done, she had done. She took a deep breath and resumed her story.

“The next morning, we met very early and we talked about what we wanted to do all that day. It was a big decision and we were both trying to look at it in the light of a new day. Finally, just before it closed, we went to the clerk's office and got our license. And then he said, 'Come with me.' We turned and went back the way we came. He was looking all around and muttering to himself and then he saw what he was looking for. We went up to the door of this house and started knocking. I stood next to him, wondering what he was doing and I looked to the window to see if anyone was coming and I saw what he had seen earlier: a sign that said, 'Notary Public.'”

“What's that?” the girl said.

“It's a person who witnesses things,” said the grandmother. “And eventually we heard someone coming down some stairs inside the house. And suddenly, knowing the notary would probably be angry at being disturbed at dinner time, I looked down and bent over and picked up the evening paper from his welcome mat. A man came to the door, and there we were, standing on his porch, holding out his newspaper to him. We told him why we were there and he was very reluctant to help us. There was no waiting period in our state, but still we had just met 24 hours ago. But we found out that the notary was once in the same branch of the service as my boyfriend—well, fiance—and when he heard how he was shipping out the next morning, he was sympathetic. He thought a while and then he and his wife and his son, who was home from college, witnessed us getting married. Only when we got to the part about the ring, we stopped. Even though we had talked about doing this all day, we had forgotten to get a ring.

“My groom was going through his pockets and I went through my purse. We couldn't find anything. And then, seeing the evening paper on the table, my soon-to-be husband pulled out his pocket knife and cut the string off of the newspaper. He started to tie a loop and then he stopped, took his knife and cut off the button I had sewn on his cuff. He threaded the string through it, tied it, cut off the excess and slipped it on my finger. And, repeating after the notary, he said, 'I give you this ring as a symbol of my vow, and with all that I am and all that I have, I honor you.' Then he added, 'And I promise before God, I will see you again.' And we kissed.”

There was a long pause, Then, quietly, not wanting to break the spell, the little girl said, “And then what?”

The grandmother came out of her reverie and her face colored a little. “We found a place to stay that night and in the morning, we ate breakfast, our last meal together. We walked to the base, we kissed and cried and I went home and...well, the rest of it wasn't very pleasant. My parents were very angry and the notary had sent off the paperwork so I didn't have anything to show them that night or for several weeks.

“And then I never heard from my husband. I followed the war news and I met the postman everyday, looking for a letter from him but it never came. And then I had your mother.”

The little girl's eyes grew round.

“The war lasted a long time. And I got no word from him. So I held onto the words he spoke when he gave me this ring. It was a sign of our vows and his promise. So I hung onto it. People made fun of me for wearing this.” She looked at the old button and frayed string. “And my parents didn't believe in him or his promise. They thought he had fed me a fairy tale. At times, it did feel like a fairy tale. I didn't even have a picture of him. There were times when I would start to forget what he looked like. But I knew he loved me and I knew what he said and I knew that he meant it. So I clung to his promise.

“Then the war was over and I waited some more. And one day a man knocked at the door. He was in a uniform, but he was very thin and I didn't recognize him. And he told me that he was a friend of my husband. They had been in the same outfit. They were captured by the enemy shortly after they had gone into the field. They were held as prisoners of war. And they were tortured.

“I became aware that I had grasped the button with my right hand as I listened to this and was twisting it until the string was cutting into my finger. So I made myself stop. I didn't want to break the string.

“The soldier told me how, at night, as they lay in their cells, my husband had spoken to him about me. After the war, the prisoners were released and this man, as soon as he got to the states, looked me up. It was hard because he had no address, just the town. But now he was here to tell me that my husband...”The woman faltered. Her eyes filled. The little girl held her breath. “My husband was in the hospital on the other side of the country.

“Well, of course, I cried and I hugged the soldier. And my mother cried and made him a big meal. And my father went to the phone and that night I flew out to see my husband for the first time since the day we got married.

“He had been very sick when the prisoners were liberated. He had wounds that hadn't been properly treated and a high fever. They said he couldn't even think or talk straight when they got him into the military hospital.They thought he would die. So as soon as his friend was released, he went to find me.

“When I got there, my husband was very thin and pale. But when he saw me, his face lit up and we kissed and cried. I told him about your mother and showed him her pictures and we kissed and cried some more. He saw the button and string around my finger and said, 'Have you worn that the whole time?' And I said I did. And I stayed until the nurse made me leave.

“The next day I went to see the chaplain and we had a proper wedding, as I had promised my father. The doctors and the nurses and the patients all put in some money and got me this ring,” said the grandmother, indicating the gold band on her left hand. “But I saved the button and string because when he was gone, this was the sign of your grandfather's word and promise. And this is what got me through his absence.”

The grandmother handed the worn button on the frayed string back to the little girl, who stared at it intently and then reverently put it in the little velvet box, snapped it shut and put it in the jewelry box, a treasure among baubles.

It was not only the way the girl saw the button and string that changed. Her grandmother, too, seemed transformed and the granddaughter thought that maybe she could see the young girl in the story in the face of the old woman. The pictures in the hall seemed sharper and brighter as she passed them, especially the fat baby that had been her mother and the skinny young soldier who had been her grandfather.

The rain had stopped and the world was dripping with new meanings. Everything and every person they saw seemed to have a hidden story and the little girl longed to hear them. Even at church where she heard again of the story of Jesus' last supper with his friends before he went off to die for them. She listened again to how he held up bread and said, “This is my body...do this in remembrance of me.” And he held up the cup of wine and said, “This is my blood...do this in remembrance of me. I will not drink the fruit of the vine until that day I drink it anew with you in my Father's kingdom.” And a realization hit her. She looked at her grandma excitedly. “It's a promise!” she whispered. The grandmother smiled back at her.

And then the people all said, “Christ has died. Christ is risen. Christ will come again.” And at the words a shiver went up her spine.

And when she went up to the altar with her grandmother, the priest handed her the pale disk and said, “The body of Christ.” She looked at it intently. It looked the same. She ate it. It tasted the same. But she felt different. Because for her the word had become flesh.

First preached on July 20, 2003. It has been updated. 

Thursday, July 4, 2024

Phyllis Todd


My kids called my mom the “educational grandma.” Because instead of getting them cool stuff for birthdays and Christmas, she would get them things they could learn with. But they didn't grow up in her household or know how infectious my mother's love of learning was at full strength.

She took us to the library twice a week sometimes. Once we would go to the Fyler branch near our home and a few days later she would take us to the Buder branch a few miles away. Because they had a limit on how many books a person could take out at any one time. My mother read voraciously. I still can't keep up with the speed with which she devoured books. But I owe my love of reading and learning to her. My greatest pleasure is still learning something new or learning something that helps me put what I've learned into a useful framework.

Neither my grandmother, nor my aunts, read that much, so I figure my mother found it a way to deal with being an only child with a prodigious intelligence, living on a farm. Not that she only read. She loved horses, She had a horse named Patches on which she learned to do trick riding, including standing on the saddle and even catching a handkerchief lying on the ground in her teeth as the horse galloped. It sounds unbelievable but I've seen the pictures.

My mother loved the outdoors, which is why we camped a lot when we were kids and why she traveled the country alone in her RV once we were grown and out of the house. She also liked hunting for and digging up wildflowers, often illegally, on winding country roads, which made my brother and I nervous when she confessed that she didn't know exactly where we were. But she always found the way home, where she would replant the flowers in her garden. And she would take us to Shaw's Garden to see the flowers and plants. She and I spread her mother's ashes there. My brother and I spread some of her ashes there as well. It is appropriate that her name Phyllis meant “foliage” and her favorite color was green. She was supposed to be named after her father Philip but my grandmother didn't know that the feminine version was Philippa. My mom was grateful for that mistake, even though Philippa means “lover of horses” and would have been equally appropriate.

My mother won a scholarship to college but her mother convinced her that going into nursing would be a more appropriate field for a woman. She became acting head of the recovery room at Jewish Hospital, the only place she ever worked. She did send herself to college later on, getting a degree in library science. She ran the medical library at the hospital and later was the tumor registrar for the Oncology department, keeping track of all cancers diagnosed or treated at the hospital, something necessary to keeping their accreditation for the American College of Surgeons.

My mom was outspoken and her opinions were usually right because she did so much research on them. She was very hard to argue with. You had better do your research first as well. I was upset to find, however, that once I could out-argue her she would just shut down the discussion. She could be infuriating.

My mother is responsible for my going to church. My earliest memory is standing on a pew. The congregation is singing a hymn. I don't know it but I want to sing as well. So I sing “Old MacDonald Had a Farm.” My mom did not correct me but looked down at me and smiled at my childish faux pas. So this was before she started losing her hearing. It's sad because she loved music and played records of tunes from her early years and operas like “Carmen,” singing along with them. My taste in music owes a bit to her as well.

We stopped going to church for a while during my elementary school years, possibly because my dad was working nights as a bartender and slept in on Sundays. But when we were “tweens” my mother started shopping around for churches. We ended up going to Memorial Presbyterian, led by the learned Rev. Dr. George Scotchmer. His sermons were very well-thought out and very long: 40 minutes on average. When I began preaching I resolved not to go for length. As Mark Twain supposedly said, “Very few sinners are converted after the first 20 minutes of a sermon.”

When Mom's hearing got so she could not follow the service she tried attending Quaker meetings where everyone is quiet for an hour unless the Spirit moves someone to speak.

My mom also introduced me to C.S. Lewis by reading and then giving to me his Screwtape Letters. His rational but conversational discussion of Christianity appealed to Mom and I. In Lewis' words about his favorite author, “my imagination was baptised.”

My mother also loved art and beauty. After church most Sundays she would take my brother and I to the art museum to eat lunch and see the exhibits or watch the series “Civilization” by Sir Kenneth Clark.

And my mom also liked to express her artistic side. She would find arts and crafts that interested her, get books on them and then buy all the supplies and start making them—embroidery, needlepoint, paintings, jewelry, chip carving, model Z train layouts. And I used the word “start” advisedly. She would get deep into them, get things half-completed and then get into a different craft or hobby. Many were the birthdays and Christmases when we were shown the gifts she was making still in-progress but never thereafter see them in finished form.

The one thing in which she achieved mastery was cake decorating. The year my dad got me a Lionel train set, she made me a train cake, with an engine and several cars on a licorice rail track with vanilla wafer sleepers. When she got me the Complete Sherlock Holmes in one volume, my cake looked like an open book and “Happy Birthday, Chris” was spelled out in the code from “The Adventure of the Dancing Men.” Cakes she made and completed.

Mom loved animals, too. We always had pets: a dog, a cat, a rabbit that got too big to be produced from my brother's magical apparatus. I remember how long she mourned Rocky the rabbit after he got out of the yard and was run over.

My mom never loved any man but my dad. Even after they divorced—twice—they saw each other frequently during the week. I think they got along better because they had neutral corners to go to, so to speak, at the end of the day. She swore she would not help him if he got sick at the end of his life—but she did. And while Dad had girlfriends during the divorces, Mom never found another man who replaced him.

My mom's last years were plagued by vascular dementia. We didn't pay much attention to her forgetfulness at first because of my dad's rapid decline during his last year. But after he died, we realized that Mom's memory and judgment were deteriorating. We wanted to keep her in the house she bought during their first divorce but eventually she couldn't live on her own.

My last memories of Mom are from February 2020. I was dismayed that during the days I visited, she was just sitting in her wheelchair, saying next to nothing, like many of the nursing home residents ravaged by dementia. And then I came at night and she was awake and active. She got up out of her wheelchair and my wife and I rushed to grab her by the arms, since she fell regularly. She started walking down the hall, dragging us to the door to the outside. She asked if either of us had a key. She explained that she was going to break out the residents of the home. She also asked if my brother had come because we'd need a car. Her brain was still working as best it could.

The last time I saw her I put her to bed in her room and kissed her on the forehead. This was a month before everything got shut down for Covid. And it was Covid that took her, several months later, on her 88th birthday.

My mother was a remarkable person. She never made the headlines or shook the world with her intelligence. But she shaped me more than I realized. And today we shatter her ashes that she might become one with the flowers and foliage she loved in one of the National Parks she visited and in which she found joy.

Tuesday, July 2, 2024

Love and Choice

 The scriptures referred to are Ephesians 1:1-14

In his book Guns, Germs and Steel scientist and historian Jared Diamond tries to answer the question of why certain peoples developed a high degree of civilization and why others didn't. In other words, why did the people who lived in Eurasia come to dominate the modern world instead of Native Americans, aboriginal Australians or Africans? He counters the implicit racist explanations by going back into prehistory. Some of the things that gave certain peoples a head start are an abundance of easily cultivated plants and domesticable animals. These things made the choice to cease being hunter-gatherers and become farmers an attractive option. Once people commit to farming and raising their food, they develop settlements which become cities and eventually nations; they make innovations and introduce efficiencies in farming that in turn produces surplus food, which frees some individuals from being farmers and allows them to specialize into other human endeavors, such as becoming builders, soldiers, artists, scientists, healers, politicians, priests and so on.

Even though he makes a good case that some people just happened to be in good farming areas, he does look at the fact that certain very suitable farming areas, like California, the Argentine pampas and the fertile coast of Australia, were not exploited until very late in history. He looks for the reasons these weren't developed by the natives but ultimately there are things we cannot know. Part of it comes down to human choice. Being a farmer can be a mixed blessing. It is hard; you are at the mercy of the weather; and even if farming gets harder, it is very difficult to simply abandon everything and move on. Some societies chose, for reasons we may never know, to simply remain hunter-gatherers.

In the beautiful doxology that opens the letter to the Ephesians, Paul lists among the spiritual blessings that God has showered upon us, the fact that “he chose us in Christ before the foundation of the world to be holy and blameless before him in love. He destined us for adoption as his children through Jesus Christ, according to the good pleasure of his will...” This and a handful of verses in the New Testament assure us that our salvation doesn't depend on our fallible human efforts or fickle human wills but on God's choice to love us and seek us out. But these same passages give some people misgivings because they seem to say that God predestined some people to be saved. And doesn't that mean he just lets others be damned? How could a loving God do that?

This is a deep theological problem and I am not going into it in detail. For one thing, the danger of arguing the notion that God predestines some people for salvation makes it easy to get trapped into arguing for double predestination: that God has chosen some people, ahead of time, to go to hell. This is the inevitable result of treating the subject with rigid human logic. Logic, which is simply a method for staying self-consistent, is an indepensable tool in some areas of thinking, such as math or physics, though even there we run into paradoxes. While logic is helpful in areas other than the hard sciences, it can lead to some peculiar stances when applied too rigorously to unpredictable and notoriously inconsistent things like human beings.

Read any comment section on the internet and you will see some very harsh and one-sided assessments of people by those with whom they disagree. It seems that Republicans are evil people who are deliberately sacrificing the welfare of the majority of citizens to enrich the few; Democrats are evil people who want to destroy hardworking people in order to give their wealth to the undeserving; people who are homeless or poor have decided to live that way rather than work; religious people are both evil and stupid; atheists are also both stupid and evil, etc. We all are prone to assume that people who make what we see as bad decisions do so perversely with full knowledge of the negative outcomes. But that's not how it is in real life. No one says, “I want to be poor or homeless.” Nobody says, “ I want to be on the wrong side of history.” Both Democrats and Republicans, fascists and communists think they are making the right decisions. And often what turns out to be a bad decision looked like a good or at least harmless one at the time. Sometimes a potentially dangerous decision seems to be worth the risk. The only way to be sure is to look at it in retrospect. We cannot judge President Truman's decision to drop the bomb on Hiroshima on the basis of what we now know about the proliferation of nuclear weapons in the world. We need to judge it by the facts that he had at that time.

It's interesting that Truman's famous saying, “The buck stops here,” goes back to the days of riverboat gambling. A buck knife rested in front of the dealer to indicate who he was and perhaps to use to defend him against accusations of cheating. He was the one responsible for shuffling and distributing the cards. But it wouldn't be a real game is the deal determined the winners. It's not just the hand you are dealt but how you play it. What you're given and what you do with it are both important to the outcome. God deals us different hands but he is not interested in who wins in the conventional sense but with how and why we use what is dealt to us and by what we keep and what we discard.

A fun type of science fiction is alternative history. Harry Turtledove loves to imagine what the world might be like if, say, America had never broken away from Britain, or if the Byzantine empire had not fallen, or if the South had won the Civil War. Sometimes he comes up with science fictional reasons for the change but sometimes he merely imagines a few changes in a few places where things might have gone differently. Other authors have done the same. What if Hitler had invaded Britain after Dunkirk? It is possible that he may have won the war and the two superpowers today would be America and Nazi-occupied Europe.

When you look back at history you see ways in which what happened seemed inevitable but also ways in which human choice played a role. Looking at Diamond's explanation of why certain peoples became dominant and others didn't gives us the same paradoxical viewpoint. Some places had more resources, so when societies made the change from hunter-gatherers to farmers, it seems inevitable. But there were always those places and societies that had the potential but didn't act on it. Why were these roads not taken?

We prize individual freedom and we like to think it is unfettered. But freedom is never total. There are always factors that limit people's choices. A Jew born in Nazi Germany had very limited choices on how to live her life, just as a black man born in the South before the Civil War would have. A person born without legs could hardly expect to grow up to be a prima ballerina. Our freedom lies within the sphere of the possible and largely within the inner circle of the probable.

And yet there are alternatives that a few find. Edith Hahn Beer, was a young Jewish law student living in Austria during World War 2. When faced with being deported to a concentration camp, she managed to create a Gentile identity with the help of a friend. She became a Red Cross nurse and was transferred to a military hospital. She ended up marrying a German officer. Her daughter was the only Jewish child born in a Nazi hospital, though only Edith knew that. Edith and her daughter survived the war and when her husband returned from a Russian prisoner of war camp, he could not live with the fact that he had married a Jew and had a Jewish child and so he divorced her. This ex-wife of a Nazi went on to become a judge after the war and married a Holocaust survivor. She lived an improbable life.

We also know of slaves who rose to prominence, like Frederick Douglass.And then there is Helen Keller, the deaf, dumb and blind girl who became a well-read woman who wrote influentially, spoke to audiences and even learned to sing!

So what is the truth? Are we what we choose to be or are we shaped by outside forces? The only adequate answer is yes to both. We are influenced by things beyond our control that limit our choices to some extent but we can make choices that in turn enlarge the range of what we can do.

So how does God operate within the world of humans making choices? Don't we choose to become Christians? Let me first ask this: Do people in love choose those with whom they fall in love? Yes and no. First of all, the decision has to be mutual. I can decide I want to fall in love with a specific person but if she doesn't decide to be in love with me, it's not going to happen. But even if it is mutual, the crucial detail of whether we ever meet in the first place and even know the other person existed is out of our hands!

I met my wife because a former girlfriend of mine, with an eye to matchmaking us, invited Julie to a going away party for a girl Julie didn't even know. And even after being introduced, we didn't show much interest in each other until my ex told me of a subject in which we were both interested and got us talking. If either of us had not gone to the party, or if I hadn't years ago had a history class with the girl who became my ex or if the ex and I hadn't become friends after initially not liking each other in history class...well, the chain of causation goes on and on. Viewed from one perspective, it was all happenstance and coincidence, but viewed from another perspective, that of being happily married nearly 50 years, it now seems inevitable.

The same thing can be seen in my evolution from a pre-teen brought to church by my mother into a teen fascinated by C.S. Lewis to a young man majoring in Biblical Studies at Wheaton College to a newlywed who entered nursing to provide him with an income that will help him go to seminary to a young father who makes more as a nurse than he would as clergy to a copywriter recruited by a Keys radio station because he produces award-winning commercials to a lay preacher asked to become a Canon 9 priest by his parish. When I look back on it from where I am now, it looks inevitable. There is a Rube Goldberg kind of round-aboutness to achieving my original goal but the destination of that path always seems to have been a matter of, not “if,” but “when.”

Our choices are important but who offers us the choices? Would Frederick Douglass have risen so far from slavery if his master's wife hadn't been disobedient and taught Douglass to read? Would Edith Beer have survived the Nazi invasion to help re-establish justice in her country if her Gentile friend hadn't lent her a non-Jewish identity? Would Helen Keller have escaped her dark silent world if her parents hadn't hired a determined Irish girl named Annie to try to break through and teach Helen sign language?

Would you have become a Christian had God not presented you with the people and circumstances that led you to him? God may choose us beforehand but we are not puppets. He doesn't force us but offers us his love. And we cannot be certain that he is not also offering his love to those around us. Even those whose conversion seems improbable may be those he is seeking most ardently.

Captain Mitsu Fuchita led the planes that bombed Pearl Harbor. He came from Japan, a nation where Christians are still a very small minority. But Christ found him and he became an evangelist. He spoke at my church when I was a teen.

Joy Davidman was an American Jewish Communist. One day her husband ran off with another woman, leaving her with their 2 small sons. Christ found her. She grew in faith through the writings of C.S. Lewis and started a correspondence with him. Later she married Lewis and influenced his writings.

Anne Lamott was an alcoholic, pill-popping woman who got pregnant by her married lover. Her dysfunctional family looked down on religion and yet she was attracted to the singing of an inner city black church. Though she always left before the sermon, Christ found her. She sobered up and has become a respected writer of hilarious, heart-breaking, Jesus-infused memoirs and fiction.

Being predestined to receive God's grace doesn't mean we had no choice nor that we are better than others. And it doesn't mean that others aren't also destined to experience God's love and forgiveness. We may very well be the matchmaker between God and the person he loves. So we must act as if every person is destined to become Christ's and as if we were merely the latest step in that process. Because we don't know...yet. But some day we will look back and see the marvelous, intricate, unanticipated and improbable journeys by which we have all come to God's love. And it will look as if it couldn't have happened any other way.

First preached on July 12, 2003. It has been updated.

Sunday, June 16, 2024

Asking the Right Questions

The scriptures referred to are Ezekiel 2:1-7, 2 Corinthians 12:2-10. and Mark 6:1-6.

I loved my mother-in-law. I'd always gotten along well with her but what I'm about to tell you made her just about my favorite person in the world. Shortly after I had been ordained, while my wife was talking to her mother on the phone, she interrupted herself to scold me for leaving the Sunday paper spread all over or some other breach of domestic etiquette. My mother-in-law, overhearing this, said to my wife, “I don't think you should yell at him anymore: he's holy!”

I need to see what I can do about having her canonized.

Wouldn't it be nice if everyone cut you some slack just because you were a Christian? Well, don't hold your breath. Nobody gave Ezekiel, Paul or Jesus a break just because they were doing God's business. And odds are people won't extend any tolerance to us either, especially if we are focused on certain things people don't want to hear about.

Take Ezekiel. Now he was one weird dude. Besides having the most bizarre visions this side of John's Revelation, Ezekiel's specialty was to act out God's messages to the people of Jerusalem. So at one point he stays in his house, mute and tied with a rope. He also draws a picture of the city of Jerusalem on a clay tablet and then lays siege to it. He lies on his left side for 390 days and on the right for 40 days, symbolizing the number of years God has put up with the sins of the northern kingdom of Israel and of the southern kingdom of Judah. He takes a sword and shaves his head and beard and weighs his hair, dividing it into thirds. A third he burns in his little drawing of Jerusalem, a third he strikes with the sword, and a third he throws into the wind, saving a few in his garment. This symbolized the fate of God's people when the Babylonians eventually attacked.

And the response of God's rebellious people to this message of justice? Not much. Ezekiel, perhaps because he is a priest, doesn't suffer the persecution of his contemporary, Jeremiah. Instead he is pretty much ignored. He goes into exile in Babylon with the cream of Judean society. There he receives a vision of the restoration of God's people after the punishment is over. But nobody responded to his message of judgment. Unfortunately, if you want to be heard, you have to tell people what they want to hear.

Jesus went back to his hometown and instead of welcome, appreciation and acceptance, he finds astonishment, offense and disbelief. Despite his powerful preaching and his acts of healing, his neighbors cannot believe that someone they grew up with, one of Mary's kids, has become anyone special. They reel off the names of Jesus' 4 brothers and remember his sisters still living in sleepy little Nazareth and they can't see anything extraordinary about them. So Mark tells us that Jesus couldn't do any great deed of power there except a few healings. (Mark 6:1-6) He couldn't do much because people weren't receptive. Jesus wasn't a magician who could change people against their will. God will only work on you if you are responsive, just as a potter can only work with soft malleable clay. Once it is dry and set, it can't be changed; it can only be broken.

Finally, we come to Paul, who, in 2 Corinthians, is forced to defend himself to one of the churches he planted. Corinth was the “Sin City” of its day and the church there had a lot of problems. Paul spent 18 months there at one point. Now he has gotten bad news about that church from his spiritual son and colleague Timothy whom he had sent to resolve things. On top of the other problems, he finds that rival “apostles”are questioning his credentials. So he feels forced to brag about his qualifications, though it goes against his judgment to do so. Do his rivals have visions? Paul's could top theirs. But he speaks of himself in the third person because he doesn't like to brag. In fact, despite his vision of paradise, he would rather talk of his afflictions. (2 Corinthians 12:2-10)

Paul speaks of a thorn in the flesh that keeps him humble. We do not know what his problem was: epilepsy, malaria, or some disfiguring ailment. A good guess might be a painful eye condition because Paul says that the Galatians would have given their own eyes to him if they could. (Galatians 4:13-15) Perhaps he saw auras preceding migraine headaches. The word translated “thorn” could also mean “sharp stake.” Anyone who's had a migraine knows it can feel as if a nail or spike was being driven into your head. Whatever it was, Paul wanted it gone. But God did not remove his affliction. Instead he gave Paul the grace to deal with it. It was not what Paul wanted. It was however what he, a brilliant man and church leader, needed to keep him from getting arrogant.

We often encounter some problem or difficulty that we wish were removed. We may tell God that we could do his work better if our life was problem-free. I remember seeing a T-shirt that read, “O Lord, let me show you how humble I could be, even if I won the lottery!” But God is smarter than that. And I have read articles about lottery winners who blow through all of their winnings and end up poor. Because if you can't manage a modest amount of money, you won't be able to manage millions. The fault lay not in their bank account but in themselves. More money only increased their problems.

What we want is an absence of problems. But God doesn't deal in avoidance of trouble. And telling people the truth rather than what they want to hear can make them ignore you, as in the case of Ezekiel, or persecute you, as in the case of Jesus. According to Luke, during one of his visits to Nazareth, his preaching in the synagogue so enraged his neighbors that they almost threw him off the cliff that the town was built on. (Luke 4:28-30) Nobody was neutral when it came to Jesus. They either recognized the truth that he spoke or tried to shut him up. But that didn't stop Jesus. And it shouldn't stop us.

While Hitler was rising to power, the reporters of the Munich Post warned the German people of his party's use of intimidation, blackmail, and even murder to move ahead of political rivals. Their relentless exposure of Nazi hypocrisy and criminality won them Hitler's epithet of “the poison kitchen.” The Munich Post continued to tell the unpalatable truth until Hitler at last achieved power and had the newspaper destroyed and its editors and writers imprisoned. They may not have stopped Hitler but they did the right thing. And you can't say that the German people had no idea of the caliber of the man who destroyed their democracy and seized control of their country.

Why do such people get power? A psychology experiment instructed people to lie about something to a person they were about to meet. Then those same people were put in a group and given a task for the group to accomplish. The disturbing observation that came out of this experiment was that the most convincing liars were often made the leaders. Explains a lot, doesn't it?

The problem, as C.S. Lewis pointed out, is that we classify information in the wrong categories. We ask if something is liberal or conservative, progressive or reactionary, a fad or traditional, popular or unpopular, politically correct or offensive, expensive or cheap. What we ought to be asking is whether it is true or false, right or wrong?

The man who headed the FBI's counter-terrorism unit and who had prevented a wave of bombings on the New Year's Eve of the new millennium warned our government about Osama Bin Ladin. But he was considered an alarmist. Nobody asked whether what he said was true or false, only if such news was welcome in the White House or not.

And then, when the planes hit the twin towers on 9/11, two preachers, Jerry Falwell and Pat Robinson, said it was divine punishment for America's tolerance of feminists, gays and the like. They faced a firestorm of criticism. The American people didn't want to hear what they said and so they backed down. Both the reaction and the retraction was about the popularity of the idea, not its merits. For the record, I think Falwell and Robinson were wrong. Jesus rejected the idea that disasters, either natural or man-made, were judgments from God. He mentioned incidents where a dictator murdered people and another where a tower fell on people. Were the victims more sinful than anyone else? Jesus asked. Of course not, he said. (Luke 13:1-5)

When we speak for God, we'd better be certain that we are right. We'd better be sure that we are not just saying what we feel or what people want to hear. But if we are certain, then we must stand by it whatever the world's reaction. Jesus gave us a grave responsibility when he told the disciples that they could declare sins forgiven or not. (John 20:23)

We live in a world that feels that it is more important to be happy than right. We live in a culture that hates the idea of making sacrifices. We live in a society where a long marriage is marveled at because it is so unusual for people to take vows and promises seriously. We live in an era where whistleblowers who alert us to wrongdoing or crimes committed by an important person are attacked as snitches or traitors if the person being accused is popular. People don't seem to care if the accusations are true or if what was done was wrong.

The problem is, whether you properly identify something as true or false, right or wrong, whether you ignore it or whether you fight against it, it doesn't change the facts. If you choose to live the lie, the truth will eventually catch up with you. If you choose to do what is wrong, you will suffer the consequences.

Harry Potter becomes furious when the wizarding world doesn't believe that the evil Lord Voldemort is back and is gathering followers. The problem is that Harry doesn't trust his ally, Professor Dumbledore, and so he makes some bad choices. We also learn that Dumbledore has been holding back some of the truth from Harry. Because these two do not confide in one another and tell the unpalatable truth to one another, someone close to Harry dies. The series says explicitly that it is about the importance of doing what's right, rather than what's easy.

Sadly in this sinful world, those who stand for the truth and what is right may suffer as well as the liars and the wrongdoers. But we mustn't let that deter us. As Ezekiel and Paul learned, and as Jesus demonstrated on the cross, whether the problem is external or internal, whether it is social, physical or spiritual, the way out is often the way through, not the way around. We must rely on God's grace, his undeserved and unreserved goodness toward us. God doesn't make the problem go away; he gives us the means to deal with it. Whether we need strength or patience or kindness or self-control or rest, if we turn to him, he will provide it. It may not always be what we think we need, but it will be what we actually need.

The world needs people who constantly remind it of what it needs. It needs people who unwaveringly point to what is right and what is true. These people will not always be heeded. They will be vilified and ostracized, or maybe ignored. They may not succeed as the world counts success. But that is not their concern. They must be faithful to their duty to God and to their fellow men and women. Because they are witnesses to God's faithfulness to his lost creatures and his desire to bring them back to his love.

Are you willing to be one of them?

First preached on July 6, 2003. There has been some updating and revising.