Wednesday, December 15, 2010

The Supporting Character

One of my favorite uncles when I was a child wasn’t really a relative at all. He was “Uncle” Don Seawooster, a friend of my father’s. And besides his gruff but lovable manner with my brother and me, what I loved about him was his hobby. He was a member of the Southtown Players, a community theater group. He performed in their plays, though rarely in a lead role, but what really fascinated me was his behind the scenes work. He built the sets and what I remember was a backstage tour of the sets for Dracula. I forget which stage version they presented but they really went all out with the special effects. A bat flew out over the audience. After drinking from one of his victims, Dracula stepped forward and suddenly blood trickled from the corner of his mouth. But the highlight was the scene in which the men hunting Dracula grab and hold him till the sun rises. As one counts down the seconds from his pocket watch, Dracula suddenly disappears, his cape dropping empty to the floor and in the form of a bat he flies out the window. Uncle Don showed us how it was done. Dracula’s cape had false shoulders and a collar higher than the actor‘s head. When grabbed, the actor playing Dracula was standing behind a sofa, facing the back wall of the set. The actors playing his hunters would grab his false shoulders. “Dracula” would untie his cape, drop to the floor and crawl out a small hinged door, rather like a cat flap, that was set into the back of the set and hidden behind the sofa. At the right time, the hunters dropped the cape and the prop bat, also behind the sofa, flew via a wire out the open window. If it weren’t for all the preparation uncle Don had done, the scene wouldn’t have worked.

Though less glamorous than acting, the folks who create the sets for a play, or a movie, or a TV show are invaluable. They help create the realty necessary to make the story believable. They set the mood, they create the world and time in which the story takes place. What would “Dracula” be if it weren’t for the castle and the doomed ship and the asylum and the crypt? Where would “The Hound of the Baskervilles” if it weren’t for the moors and the Grimpen mire and the stone age dwellings? Where would Holmes himself be if it were not for London, that “cesspool of crime?”

And even among the actors, those who play supporting roles, are still vital. In the original Sherlock Holmes story, as in the new updated series, it is an otherwise forgettable character named Stamford who introduces Watson to Holmes. Scrooge is the central character of “a Christmas Carol” but a pivotal scene would be missed were it not for the boy in the street he hails at random to ask if it is Christmas Day and then sends to get the big turkey at the butcher shop and deliver it to the Cratchits. Would you continue to watch “The Matrix” or care who Neo if it weren’t for Morpheus, the man who initiates Tom Anderson and keeps telling us who he is to become?

John the Baptist has that thankless task in the gospel. He is the herald who goes before the anointed king to announce his arrival. John doesn’t mind the role assigned to him but once imprisoned by Herod Antipas, he starts to wonder, is Jesus really the one?

Why would John doubt? Was it because he was in prison and in danger of being executed? Sometimes even believers start to doubt God when things go bad for them. Maybe a prayer is not answered, or rather, not answered as we would like. Maybe it’s a disease or a disaster or a death. Maybe it’s a wayward child. Or a reversal of your fortune or career. It wasn’t what you expected. Or what you deserved as a believer in God. What’s the good of following Jesus if you aren’t exempt from the same trials and troubles other people suffer?

People are always looking for a way in which to magically eliminate suffering in this life. And a lot of people think God promises his followers that they won’t have to undergo anything really unpleasant. But Jesus said just the opposite: “in this world you have trouble and suffering…” There is no promise that Christians are immune to having bad things happen to them. Jesus wasn’t. There is no magic in this life that allows for actions without consequences. We are most certainly not exempt from having to dealing with the fallout of following Jesus. We still have to take a stand and do the right thing, even if it costs us. For that reason Jesus added “…but take courage--I have conquered the world.”

But I doubt that John the Baptist thought that doing God’s work meant a painless existence. He was a prophet and he knew what happened to a lot of the prophets in the Old Testament. Besides he doesn’t ask Jesus to magically get him out of prison.

There is another possibility. John preached of how the axe was laid to the root, of how God’s judgment was imminent, of how the Kingdom of God was near. And yet, where was that day of judgment? Even in prison, John should have heard of the inauguration of the righteous reign of God’s Messiah. So he sends his disciples to Jesus to ask if he is indeed the one. The implication is, perhaps, why isn’t the kingdom here already?

John might be confusing the 2 separate pictures one gets of the Messiah in the Old Testament. One was of David Redux, God’s warrior-king who would end the present evil age and usher in the Kingdom of God. The other was Isaiah’s picture of the Suffering Servant, who takes on the sins of his people. You can guess which one was more popular with the oppressed Jews. They wanted a fighter, not a martyr.

Some thought the portraits were of 2 separate persons. Perhaps the Suffering Servant was the prophet Jeremiah. Or the Jewish people as a whole. Though there were rabbis who thought that the Suffering Servant was indeed the Messiah, the majority thought the two were separate entities. What no one seems to have realized is that this was one person on two different occasions.

Jesus comes first as the servant whose spilled blood would supersede that of the animals sacrificed in the Temple and atone for the sins not just of his people but of the whole world. Mere physical conquest will not make people willing citizens of God’s kingdom. Modern generals realize that you must win hearts and minds first. This Jesus does by taking on himself all the punishment every individual deserves for his or her sins and acts of injustice. With God’s mercy offered to all, with all slates wiped clean, it is possible for anyone to be accepted as a child of God and a citizen of his kingdom. So first Jesus had to come as the suffering servant.

Did John not perceive this? Didn’t he call Jesus the Lamb of God, which is as good as saying he’s meant as a sacrifice? Yes but perhaps he was surprised by Jesus’ low key approach to ministry, as opposed to John’s fiery stance. Jesus did not emphasize God’s judgment to the extent John did. Or perhaps John was simply impatient. Maybe that’s why he asked if Jesus, like John, was just another forerunner. That might explain the delay.

Jesus answers by telling John’s disciples to relay what they see--“the blind receive their sight, the lame walk, the lepers are cleansed, the deaf hear, the dead are raised, and the poor have the good news brought to them.” In doing so, Jesus is referring to Isaiah chapters 26, 35 and 61. In other words, he is doing the work of the Messiah. And Jesus adds a little rebuke: “blessed is the one who is not scandalized by me.”

There are a lot of Christians who are scandalized by Jesus or at least some of the things he did or said. There are those who think he wasn’t tough enough on sin and those who think he talked way too much about hell. There are those who wished he said less about the end times and those who felt he didn’t say enough. There are those who think he wasn’t inclusive enough when it comes to other faiths and those who think he wasn’t exclusive enough when it comes to certain Christians. There are those who ignore what he said about the rich and those who ignore what he said about the poor. There are those who would like to purge the virgin birth from the gospels and those who would like to erase the resurrection. And then there are those who feel he should have talked more like Paul. It’s interesting that at a time when we are supposed to tolerate everyone and respect their opinions, there are people who won’t let Jesus be Jesus. We want him to be more like us.

Or maybe John was like the guy who told Jesus, “I do believe; help my unbelief.” Maybe as he sat in that dark cell, knowing he’d never see or be outside again, never feel the sun on his back and the cool Jordan river lapping at his thighs, never taste wild honey or see a former sinner rise newly born from the water, he just needed some encouragement, some word from Jesus. He never saw Christ preach or heal; Jesus began his ministry after John was arrested. And maybe John just wanted to hear firsthand that his cousin was carrying out his mission. Hopefully, the word his disciples brought back helped John face the day when Herod would have his head.

One day, when the gospel has spread to all the world, and God knows that all who will accept his reconciliation have done so, Jesus will return, close the book on evil and injustice and take his throne, ushering in his peaceable kingdom. There are times, when pain and sorrow and man’s inhumanity to man assail us, that we wish it were today. Of course, as long as we still add to that pain and sorrow, we might want to rethink that. And we’ve no excuse not to be opening the eyes of the spiritually blind, helping those who stumble get back on their feet, bringing in the social lepers, getting through to the morally tone-deaf, reanimating the spiritually dead, and bringing good news to the poor. God may forgive us but he won’t allow himself to be gamed. As John said, we need to repent, change our minds and turn our lives around. Unlike him, we are free to act. Maybe that’s why though no natural born person is greater than John, we who are born of the Spirit can be greater still. John’s a tough act to follow but Jesus says we can. And who are we to contradict Jesus?

Saturday, December 11, 2010

Shoot

Even safely ensconced in a motel in Wildwood, Florida, we had some idea of the devastation Hurricane Georges had done to our yard. A friend who had sat out the windstorm in the Keys drove by our property and phoned us with a basic report. We knew some of our trees were down but we were happy that the house was relatively unscathed. However, actually seeing the damage done to our trees was hard. One had fallen right across our driveway and would have to be cut up before we could even park on our property. A few more had snapped or split. They had to be sawn into pieces and hauled out to the street for pick up. That became my early morning task before work every day for a week. We wrote off all of those trees. But come spring we were surprised to see a stump in our backyard was sending out a riot of small green shoots. They replaced the missing part of the trunk with a bouquet of branches and foliage. The stump we thought dead was not only resurrected but was more robust than ever.

A similar image opens our passage from Isaiah 11. The previous chapter uses the image of trees being cut down as a metaphor for God’s judgment on the nations. One of the countries judged is Israel for its bad treatment of the poor. It says in Isaiah 10: “Ah, you who make iniquitous decrees, who write oppressive statutes, to turn aside the needy from justice and to rob the poor of my people of their right, that widows may be your spoil, and that you may make the orphans your prey!” This is one of God’s primary criteria for acceptable moral behavior. In Matthew 25, Jesus puts it this way: “just as you did it to one of the least of these my siblings, you did it to me.” God’s Son didn’t just defend the poor; he identified with them. So this weighs heavily in God’s judgment, even when it comes to God’s own people.

But after that, the stump, the remnant of Israel, will bring forth life. A shoot will come out of it, specifically out of Jesse, King David’s father. Quite frankly, not all of David’s descendants were good or even wise kings. So Isaiah is saying that one just as good as David, one from the same stock that brought forth the shepherd-king, is coming. And the Spirit of the Lord will rest upon him.

Initially, being anointed with the Spirit of the Lord was a qualification to be king in Israel. It was true of Saul and David and Solomon. But that soon ceased to be a consideration. Israel and Judah split. In Judah, the main criterion for a king was descent from David. In Israel, dynasties would be set up, run a while and then be bloodily overthrown. The days when the king was a man after God’s own heart were long gone. Here God is reassuring his people that a king like that, a king greater than that, will rule again.

It is interesting that the nature of the Spirit of God is spelled out. The Spirit is one of wisdom and understanding. The word for wisdom could equally be translated “common sense.” Unlike the so-called spiritual wisdom that many peddle, God’s wisdom isn’t that esoteric. The Book of Proverbs, one of the Bible’s books of wisdom literature, is very direct and practical. The thing that makes God’s wisdom hard for the world to understand are its values. It prizes substance over appearance, justice over the status quo, and truth over propriety. And it factors eternal life into moral equations, making what we do in this life extremely important while paradoxically telling us that we should not do whatever it takes to hold onto our earthly life.

At bible.org, the Net Bible, pointing out that wisdom and understanding are synonyms, translates this phrase “a spirit that gives extraordinary wisdom.” This is also linked, in the footnotes, with verse 11:3 about this future king dispensing justice fairly. So the wisdom here is specifically to be used in carrying out justice towards those who have neither the power or wealth to influence the court. Remember that you had no independent judiciary at that time. Tribal leaders also judged disputes and matters of law. The king was the final judge. If they were corrupt, you couldn’t appeal or go to the media. If your dispute was with one of the elders, you were screwed. God assures us that this promised king will be truly just.

Then we are told that this king will be anointed with the spirit of counsel and strength. Again the Net Bible combines these into the phrase “a spirit that provides the ability to execute plans.” Many leaders have the power to get things done but their plans aren’t the wisest. Others have great plans but can’t seem to get them implemented. But this king will not only have excellent plans but will be able to see that they become reality. He will be wise and strong.

This promised king will be anointed with a spirit of knowledge and fear of the Lord. Because of the parallelism we are not talking general knowledge here but knowledge of God. And fear of the Lord doesn’t mean an attitude of abject terror as if he were a movie villain prone to killing his underlings for the slightest error. Rather it is a healthy respect of God and his authority. Recently President Obama was playing basketball with some friends and aides when one of them clipped him and split his lip to the extent that stitches were necessary. I’m sure that (a) it wasn’t done deliberately and (b) that the person who did so didn’t treat it as nothing. I’ll bet he was mortified at spilling the blood of his commander in chief, despite the fact that he was not in danger of being shot for it. It’s a matter of respecting the office. It’s the same with the fear of God.

Once more I like how the Net Bible translates this phrase: “a spirit that produces absolute loyalty to the Lord.” In the case of God, it’s not just his position that one respects but his nature: just but forgiving, loving but firm in his principles. To know God is not simply to respect him but to trust him and love him and be faithful to him. This delights God’s promised king, as the first part of verse 3 reminds us. And respect for God leads to obedience to him, something even modern Christians forget.

The rest of verse 3 emphasizes the justice of this king. As the Net Bible renders it: “ he will not judge by mere appearances, or make decisions on the basis of hearsay.” Sadly, as the brother says in the independent film “Little Miss Sunshine,” much of life is a beauty contest. Studies have shown that good looking people tend to get better treatment from authorities and the legal system. In addition, people would be more likely to attribute a crime to a poor person than a middle or upper class one. But God is not fooled; he looks at the heart, as will this promised king. And unlike the world, he will not listen to hearsay but judge on the facts alone.

The king’s judgment is the subject of next couple of verses. Not only will he judge the poor fairly, he will not let the wicked get away with their deeds.

And then the focus of the passage changes. We are given images of predators and prey, the deadly and the harmless, living together in harmony. The result of justice, of everyone truly getting what they deserve, should be peace. In this world it is not easy to reconcile the two. Go for strict justice, punish all wrongdoing, and you can destroy chances for peace. Make peace paramount and you might have to ignore injustice. But in God’s kingdom, through the forgiveness only the rightful judge of all the earth can grant, justice and peace kiss each other. As the Net Bible puts it, “they will no longer injure or destroy on my entire royal mountain.” Right now, the Muslims worship at the Dome of the Rock on the top of Mount Zion, once the site of Jerusalem's Temple, and the Jews worship at the Wailing Wall below, the only extant ruins of the Temple. The wrong person in the wrong place doing the wrong thing could cause a riot. But when the rightful king, promised by God, comes to claim his inheritance, Zion will be ground zero for the peace of God. And it will spread over the earth as the waters cover the seas.

God’s promised king is, of course, his son, Jesus the Christ, the Messiah, the Anointed one. And the culmination of his kingdom is what we look for in anticipation. But we are not just to sit and wait. We are to start spreading the word, planting the seeds, laying the foundation, recruiting citizens, making disciples and working for justice and peace. And we live in a unique time. When the Bible was written, the average person could do little to affect society as a whole. All power resided with the rich and the rulers. They couldn’t be voted out. They couldn’t be impeached. They couldn’t be pressured by the media. Whereas the average person could be arrested, tortured, and executed pretty much at the will of those in power. So people looked forward to the promise of the Messiah, who would bring about the kingdom of God.

We can, however, affect those in power. We can do things that can spread at the speed of the internet all around the world. And I’m not just talking about politics. I’m talking about starting and joining ministries and programs. I’m talking about taking action as individuals and as groups. I’m talking about beginning discussions on needs and injustices. We shall not see the complete kingdom of God until Jesus returns, but we can plant the seeds, we can pull the weeds, we can water and nurture and protect what grows, knowing that the largest of trees started out as a tender shoot, just as the greatest king ever to live started out as a baby.

Friday, December 10, 2010

Godgerel

Transformation

The Creator or heaven and earth
Once became a man of low birth.
Though his words the poor thrilled,
By the rich he was killed.
But he rose, changing myrrh into mirth.

Joyful Noise
A song for kids of all ages

Make the Lord a joyful noise,
All you girls and boys!
It's such a Hallelujah day!
It's such a Hallelujah day!
Count your blessings and rejoice!
Oh, lift up your voice!
It's such a Hallelujah day!
It's such a Hallelujah day!

God made the world with power,
And when we turned things sour,
He saw the fix we're in,
And Jesus paid for all our sin.

Hallelujah, hallelujah, hallelujah--Hey!

Make the Lord a joyful noise,
All you girls and boys!
It's such a Hallelujah day!
It's such a Hallelujah day!
Count your blessings and rejoice!
Oh, lift up your voice!
It's such a Hallelujah day!
It's such a Hallelujah day!

Oh, let the heavenly chorus
Praise Jesus who died for us!
Sing to the Risen Son
For all the glorious things he's done!

Hallelujah, hallelujah, hallelujah--Hey!

Make the Lord a joyful noise,
All you girls and boys!
It's such a Hallelujah day!
It's such a Hallelujah day!
Count your blessings and rejoice!
Oh, lift up your voice!
It's such a Hallelujah day!
It's such a Hallelujah day!

And let us really hear it
For God the Holy Spirit!
'Cause he remakes us
So we'll be whole when Jesus takes us!

Hallelujah, hallelujah, hallelujah--Hey!

Make the Lord a joyful noise,
All you girls and boys!
It's such a Hallelujah day!
It's such a Hallelujah day!
Count your blessings and rejoice!
Oh, lift up your voice!
It's such a Hallelujah day!
It's such a Hallelujah day!

It's such a Hallelujah day!
It's such a Hallelujah day!
Hallelujah, hallelujah, hallelujah, hallelujah

Hallelujah, Amen!

Tuesday, December 7, 2010

Turn Around

This is out of chronological order, so that I could post my Thanksgiving sermon closer to that date.

Roger Ailes, the chairman of Fox News, got into trouble for name-calling a few weeks ago. He was criticizing the folks at National Public Radio for firing commentator Juan Williams for what he said on Fox News. Ailes called them Nazis. The odd thing is that those who objected to his words were not the people at NPR, who might have pointed out that the Nazis silenced political opponents through murder, nor even the American Nazi Party, or as it’s now called, the National Socialist White People’s Party, who might not have appreciated being likened to an organization that has shows hosted by non-whites and Jews. Instead Ailes had to apologize to the Jewish Anti-Defamation League not only for using the name inaccurately but for trivializing the ideology that conceived and carried out the Holocaust. Ailes was just doing what is acceptable in politics these days: trying to redefine your enemy by sticking him with a bad name. He just overdid it.

Names can be powerful. Few people agree with Shakespeare’s Romeo when he says, “What’s in a name? That which we call a rose by any other name would smell as sweet.” Perhaps, but not many would venture to take a sniff of something called a skunk cabbage. I doubt whether John Wayne’s name would have become a synonym for masculinity had he not changed it from Marion Morrison. And you have to ask why a bookkeeping firm took its name from the small South Dakota town in which it’s located, especially since that makes it “Crooks Accounting.”

Most companies today spend a lot of time and money trying to pick good names for themselves and their products. And they spend even more protecting those names. There is now a company called “Reputation Defender” that controls what people find on the internet when they Google you or your company. As Shakespeare writes in Othello, “he that filches from me my good name robs me of that which not enriches him and makes me poor indeed.” If you lose your good name, it is almost impossible to restore it.

Which is the problem the church faces today. Only nobody did it to us. Christ’s enemies couldn’t have done a better job at tainting the name of his people than they have done themselves. Pedophilia, corruption, lawsuits, hypocrisy, playing politics, property fights, racism, divisive theological debates, jurisdictional disputes, and self-righteousness are what we are known for putting our energies into, rather than love, joy peace, patience, kindness, generosity. gentleness, faithfulness and self-control. We have put our agendas above God’s. And the church has acted little differently than any secular organization. That is, its primary mission has become perpetuating the organization, over spreading the gospel and loving God and others.

The good news is that surveys show that people generally like Jesus even if they have problems with the church. But popularity is not the issue. Jesus needs followers, not fans. The church is supposed to be made up of his followers but we are hardly a good advertisement for recruitment.

It’s not that the church isn’t doing good things. We bring medicine and education to the poor and the far off. We bring food and agricultural equipment and knowledge. We care for the orphaned, the outcast, and the oppressed. We give voice to the voiceless. Everyday all over the world we do this. But it’s not as exciting as a really nasty quarrel over sexuality or evolution. So the media, even the Christian media, highlight the scandalous and controversial. And that well never runs dry.

How can we repair the damage done to the once good name of the church? Well, there’s no magical solution. It will take hard work and a change in attitude--attitudes, actually, towards a number of things.

First, we must change our attitude towards the meaning of success. It does not lie in numbers, either of pews occupied or of money given. In fact, those sorts of things really took on primacy during the industrial revolution. Before that, what mattered is how well you did things, not how many things you made. The house of Stradivari was known for the quality of their instruments, not the quantity. Part of the reason so many churchgoers are ignorant of their faith and how they should live is that we have been more interested in making them into return customers than into disciples.

We see them as paying customers as well. While we shouldn’t abandon sound business practices, neither should we forget that raising money isn’t our primary purpose. Putting too much emphasis on money distorts our priorities. I know churches that tolerate certain behaviors on the part of some members, or which back away from much needed changes out of fear of offending big contributors. In the secular world, right or wrong, the wealthy call the shots. The church doesn’t need to mirror that practice, especially if it diverts us from what we ought to be doing.

Next, we must change our attitude towards the importance of unity. On the night he was betrayed, Jesus prayed for the unity of the church, not its uniformity. He commanded us to love one another, not agree on everything. In fact, if we agreed on everything, we wouldn’t need a commandment to love each other. We seem to put other things above unity, specifically pet theological or social issues. I’m not saying some of these issues aren’t important, just that they shouldn’t take priority over the things that are essential. What a terrific witness to this fractious world it would be if the church was able to function despite its disagreement over important matters.

We need to change our attitude about worship. We are treating it more and more like putting on a show rather than on calling people to adoration, confession, pardon, communion and praise. It’s easy to shift from focusing on God to worrying about keeping the customers happy. And it turns participants into a passive and picky audience, looking to be entertained.

We need to change our attitude about what our duty to the church is. We shouldn’t be sacrificing individuals for the good of the institution. We need to be open about mistakes and evil actions committed by people in the church. As we’ve seen, cover-ups only delay revelations of wrongdoing and reduce people’s trust in the church. Trying to protect our name can hurt it.

There are also things we need to stop doing. One thing we need to resist is commenting on every hot political topic. Jesus’ opponents kept trying to get him to make pronouncements on the burning political issues of his day--taxes, for instance. His statement that we should give God what belongs to him and Caesar what belongs to him is a bit of an evasion, in that it doesn’t give helpful specifics. I think Jesus intentionally wasn’t getting into the details of a volatile political problem.

We can’t avoid certain social issues where clear moral principles are at stake but we needn’t make religious rulings on every popular contemporary concern. For one thing, we shouldn’t spread the mistaken idea that there is one true Christian position on every problem facing us as a society. Let us concede that there are good Christians on almost every side of some issues. Not to do so is to succumb to the modern tendency to oversimplify complex questions and needlessly polarize people.

We can imitate Jesus’ switching the emphasis from the theological technicalities of certain situations to practical ways to help. When Jesus was asked whose sin it was that caused a man to be born blind, he said that as far as he was concerned, the man was in that condition so that the power of God could be demonstrated in his healing. In the same way, Jesus doesn’t really answer the question of Mosaic law justifying the stoning of the woman taken in adultery. He adds a new consideration that makes it impossible for her accusers to execute her. Just as with taxes, Jesus sidestepped the debatable in favor of the practical. Jesus’ approach to matters in which someone was getting hurt was to relieve the suffering. He didn’t excuse sin anymore than he let an illness continue but he forgave it and healed it and gave the person a fresh start at a spiritually and physically healthy life.

In fact, the main thing we can do as a church is act more like Jesus. And that means risking our existence as a church. In Luke 23:33-43 we see Jesus at his most iconic--nailed to the cross. At Calvary, there’s no cavalry coming to the rescue. Jesus was going to die. But he was still ministering to the needs of others, in this case a robber being executed with him. If the church gets so concerned about surviving at all costs, it will make changes that will cause it to lose its moral authority. There are some matters on which it must stand, though it looks as if it will suffer the ultimate cost.

And ironically enough, research has shown that, throughout history, the parts of the church that grow are those considered outside the mainstream. Right now that means Pentecostalism and Eastern Orthodoxy and even Evangelicalism in countries where that’s something new and cutting edge. People turn to the church for things they don’t find in popular culture. So it is a mistake for us to fall into the role religion typically plays in society, that of giving its blessing to the status quo. Just like Jesus, we need to be counter-cultural. On certain matters, when the zeitgeist zigs we should zag.

In Colossians 1:11-20, Paul presents us with a very exalted view of Jesus. Then he links that to the church. If in Christ “all the fullness of God was pleased to dwell and through him God was pleased to reconcile to himself all things” and if we are his body on earth, then that should apply to us as well. Why doesn’t it? For one thing, we forget that Jesus assured us that the gates of Hell would not prevail against the church. We react too often in fear instead of faith. But Jesus, facing death, said to his father “not my will but yours be done.” We need to do the same.

And we need to take up our commission not with arrogance but with humility. In C.S. Lewis’ “Prince Caspian” when the title character is offered the kingship of Narnia, he says he doesn’t feel sufficient to be king. Aslan, the Christ of that world, says that if he had felt sufficient, it would have been proof that he wasn’t. Whereas the world wants people who act as if they can do it all, Jesus wants people who know they can’t, whose confidence doesn’t rest in themselves but in him.

Today is the last Sunday of Pentecost, the feast of Christ the King. He promised that we too would reign in the new creation. Jesus set the bar high. He said we would do greater things than he. But his glory was not that of worldly popularity. He was glorified by going to the cross for doing what was unpopular but right. He came not to be served but to serve. He said that only those willing to take up their cross and risk losing their lives would find life. Only that way can we resurrect the good name of God’s people. I don’t know about you but that scares me. I’m not sure I can do that. But I know that I can do all things through Christ who strengthens me. And so can you.

Thursday, December 2, 2010

Dayenu

A few years ago our parish held an Passover seder with our friends at the Lutheran church down the street. If you were there, you may remember that we sang a very infectious song called “Dayenu.” The title of the song is also its refrain and it’s Hebrew for “that would have been enough.” The verses of the song list the things God did for his people at the Exodus, such as “if God led us out of Egypt, but he did not part the waters--if he led us out of Egypt, dayenu.” Or “if God brought us to Mount Sinai, but not given us commandments--if he brought us to Mount Sinai, dayenu.” The chorus is that word over and over. What I find interesting is that at each point in the story, we sing that if God’s providence had stopped there, that would have been sufficient for us. The cumulative effect is to see each step of the process of liberating these slaves, making a covenant with them, adopting them as god’s people and giving them a homeland as a separate occasion to thank God. At the end, having sung their way through the whole saga, the worshippers are left contemplating a huge heap of blessings.

Last Thursday was Thanksgiving. Like most of our holidays, it has become an excuse to consume more food and drink than normal and, the day after, to buy lots of commercial goods. Originally, it was a harvest meal, thanking God for getting a group of Europeans through a harrowing time. Scholars disagree as to what group did this first and in what year. A couple of teachers from the University of Florida say the first such celebration was held by Spanish explorers on September 8, 1565 in what is now St. Augustine, Florida! Others argue for a day in 1619 in Virginia. Still others hold to the traditional year of 1621 in Massachusetts when the pilgrims of the Plymouth Plantation celebrated with Native Americans of the Patuxet tribe, without whose help the settlers would have starved.

Regardless of which celebration was the first, the holiday originally was about gratitude. And gratitude, both science and scripture teach us, is good for us. Keeping a gratitude journal, in which one lists daily 3 things or persons for which one is thankful, is an effective measure for dissipating stress and negative feelings. When you keep reminding yourself of the things for which you can thank God, it begins to change the way you look at life--emphasizing pleasures, love, and friends.

I was thinking how this Thanksgiving, I am grateful for my family--how supportive they are and how fortunate we are to appreciate and enjoy each other’s presence. For some families, coming together for a major holiday is a bit like negotiating a truce. But we like each other and like getting together to share our enthusiasms with each other. We don’t ignore our foibles but if they come up, we joke about them and take the jokes in good spirits. No one thinks they are perfect or that the others should be. We let the picky eater taste and spice the food. We not only laugh at the incorrigible joker’s bad puns, we enjoy the eye-rolling reaction of other family members.(Which is often funnier than the joke.) We use the know-it-all as a walking encyclopedia. We let the bureaucrat plow through the paperwork that confuses and infuriates the rest of us. We listen to the critics of things we should read, see, buy or do and either follow their recommendations or do the opposite, depending on whether their tastes and ours tend to run along the same lines or diverge. If that were all I had, dayenu--it would be enough.

I am grateful for my parish. It has sustained me and my family for decades. I am grateful to have been called to this particular form of serving God through the people at St. Francis-in-the-Keys. I am grateful for the support I got learning this role. I am grateful, too, as my secular jobs have come and gone, and I began to wonder, against all the objective evidence that it was in fact systemic economic problems, if there was something wrong with me, that this church has affirmed that I am a valuable member of the community. I am grateful that ministering to this parish has challenged me to move out of the comfort zone of my introversion and made me discover social gifts I didn’t know I had and develop them. This, I hope you realize, is a work in progress. If that were all I had, dayenu.

I am grateful for the fact that having to preach more than 50 times a year has made me dig deeper into the substance of my faith and the various ways that the gospel can be explored, expressed and celebrated. I am grateful to be able to share and bless and find meaning in the transitional moments in your lives--your baptisms, weddings, even burials. I am grateful for all of the people who have stepped up to the challenge of keeping this parish running by cleaning the church, repairing it, setting up the altar, reading the Lectionary, serving at the Eucharist, doing the bulletins, playing the music, making the deposits, paying the bills, serving on the vestry, leading Bible studies, taking care of the coffee hour and organizing events. If that were all I had, dayenu.

I am grateful for my present nursing job: helping a human being with a rough start but a jubilant spirit grow and discover the beauty of this world for the first time. It is amazing to watch a baby look at his hand and figure out that it is part of him and that it works a certain way and that it can help him bring to his mouth what he wants--a toy, a bottle, my pen. It is marvelous to hear him try out his voice with all manner of high pitched noises, determined grunts and contented coos. It is wonderful to sing to him and have him smile at the tunes and rhythms of nonsense songs, mother goose rhymes and hymns, or play Bach and Beethoven and watch him listen intently to the soaring melodies and roaring orchestrations, or rock him and feel him succumb to the sleep he desperately fights but deeply needs. After more than a half a century it is good to be reminded once again that everyday things like baths and food and hugs and the sun and trees and dogs and your sister and your mother are to be greeted with a big smile and swinging arms and feet kicking the air in joyful anticipation. If that were all I had, dayenu.

But this all presupposes the one who brings us here. I am grateful for God our creator, who made the world and all its inhabitants--animal, vegetable and mineral. I am grateful for the climate and environment of the Florida Keys. I am grateful for the human body, its amazing intricacy and paradoxical strengths and weaknesses. I am grateful for our brains which enable us to figure out how the things of this universe work and conceive of ways to help us conquer our weaknesses. I am grateful for our spirits, which set us apart from our fellow inhabitants and drive us to create music and stories and art and dance and jokes and philosophical questions and noble endeavors. If that were all I had, dayenu.

I am grateful for Jesus Christ, the God too big to imagine focused in terms we understand: time and space and humanity. I am grateful for his teachings about God and love and trust and peace and forgiveness and moral behavior. I am grateful for the things Jesus did to show us how beings both divine and human should act in the face of the evil of this world. I am grateful for his self-sacrificial action in going to the cross for my sins, giving up his life to give me a new life. I am grateful that God raised him from the dead, to vindicate his words and works and to assure us that our Heavenly Father is God of the living and not the dead. If that were all i had, dayenu.

I am grateful for the gift of God’s Holy Spirit, who brings the life and love of God into our very hearts and minds. I am grateful for his patient work in me, teaching me God’s wisdom, encouraging me to trust God, changing me into someone worthy to be called a child of God, and binding me to God and Christ and to the people who are his body on earth. I am grateful for his communicating to my Heavenly Father things too deep for me to express. I am grateful to the ways he speaks to me, not in words but in ideas that burst upon me like fireworks, illuminating things that I was previously was unable to see. I am grateful for how he is always there when I need him, giving me hope and energy and love when I have none of my own left. If this were all I had, dayenu.

There are many more things for which I am grateful. Some of them are the same things you are grateful for. Others are unique to each of us. I hope that sometime during this holiday you have taken time to think about all the things for which you are grateful, both big and small, general and specific, cosmic and comic. And as we enter Advent, the approach of God’s greatest gift to us, I hope you make a practice of gratitude, in your prayers and as you review each day. Start by contemplating the marvel of life itself and your body, from the way your heart keeps pumping and your lungs keep working to all the things you can do voluntarily, merely by thinking of doing them. Then go through each person you know and love. Work your way up to God and Christ and the Spirit and all things heavenly. And at each step, after each gift, say “dayenu.” If this were all, it would be enough. And then go on to the next gift. Because the blessings of God are neverending

Monday, November 22, 2010

Reconciling the Physical and the Spiritual

There’s a kind of war going on in scientific circles. Some scientists are trying to diminish the things that make humans unique from the other animals. Our use of tools? Chimps, birds, elephants, dolphins and octopi also use tools. Opposable thumbs? Most primates have them. The importance of the relative brain size of humans compared to other creatures is disputed as well. Even chimps and African Grey parrots seem to be able to learn and use language appropriately. There is nothing that human beings have that is not possessed in some degree by the other animals.

On the other hand, there are scientists who point out significant differences in humans, such as our upright posture, our shoulder, our throat, our smaller jaw, our ability to cry tears, and our sheer versatility. There’s the fact that, unlike all other animals, humans are not limited to one climate or region or continent. And we don’t adapt by changing our physiology but through developing our technology. Which, though tools, are considerably more sophisticated than those other animals create and use. The difference in the DNA of humans and chimps may be less than 2% but the fact remains that the most versatile tool chimps have devised is the stick. My not very smart phone can wake me up, keep track of my appointments, take photos and videos, play music, check my emails, give me a ten day weather forecast, my location by GPS and access the web including an online medical dictionary, several translations of the Bible, and Wikipedia. At some point differences in degree are so great that they might as well be differences in kind. St. Francis-in-the-Keys and Canterbury Cathedral are both Anglican churches but the differences in size and complexity are so vast that any detailed comparison would only serve to highlight the dissimilarities.

Still, biologically, we are mammals. And that brings us to our sermon suggestion question. It concerns “the duality of human nature--animal vs. spiritual. How to resolve the dichotomy without neglecting either side or self-destructive.” It’s an old question. The Greeks wrestled with it and decided we were spiritual beings trapped in physical bodies. The Gnostics smuggled that idea into the church. But the Bible sees us as the union of body and spirit. In Genesis 2, God forms Adam from the earth and breathes into him the breath or spirit of life. The 2 can only be separated in theory or by death. Contrary to popular belief, Christians don’t believe in a disembodied afterlife but, as we say in the Creed, “the resurrection of the dead.” God plans to reintegrate our bodies and spirits, or as John Polkinghorne puts it, save our software and install it in new hardware.

After all, if God became incarnate in Jesus Christ, then our bodies cannot be inherently bad. And indeed, they come with an operating system that allows us to learn how to walk, use language, even to seek God. But just as computer software is built on earlier versions, so we have programming that comes from our animal heritage. We are inborn tendencies to fright, to fight, to reproduce. and we need to control these proclivities lest our lives and our societies devolve into chaos. Yet we have physical needs that we cannot ignore. How does one achieve balance?

One way is to understand what those needs are and what they aren’t. For instance, we need food and water. Healthy food, of course, and neither too little nor too much. And that’s a good way to deal with all of our needs: in moderation. We need clothing, shelter, sleep and the healthiest option is always somewhere between too much and too little. Or as Goldilocks put it--just right.

A good deal of our problems with our bodies is paying them too little or too much attention. Too little and we can fall into extreme asceticism, a form of self-denial that goes beyond reasonable self-discipline. This is something Paul cautioned against in his first letter to Timothy. He warns his protégé against those who “forbid marriage and demand abstinence from foods…for everything created by God is good, and nothing is to be rejected, provided it is received with thanksgiving, for it is sanctified by God’s word and prayer.” We should not reject the good things God has created for us to use and enjoy.

On the other hand, just as eating or drinking too much is unhealthy, so is overindulgence in our other needs. We need clothing but we all know people who pay too much attention to clothing and have way too many clothes than is reasonable. We need shelter but nobody needs a mansion unless they have an extremely large family. There really is too much of a good thing.

I drew much of my list of needs from the lower tier of Maslow’s hierarchy of needs. But I think he has mislabeled one of the things on the list of physical needs: sex. Maslow should have put physical affection in there instead. The lack of physical affection can cause babies to die, even if their other physical needs are met. Those who survive have severe psychological problems. Physical touch lowers blood pressure, relieves stress and releases oxytocin, the chemical that binds humans. Physical affection is a need, even if it’s just a hug.

Sex, while definitely a need in regards to perpetuating the species, is not, strictly speaking, an individual need. The desire for it, though, is strong enough to feel as if it were. Even animals recognize that the desire for sex can and should be controlled for the common good. Among most social animals, only an alpha male or a queen or an alpha couple are allowed to mate. The others may not, often at the risk of expulsion from the pack or family, or even on pain of death. Unlike lack of food, water, or even exposure to the elements, going without sex won’t kill you. Overindulging, on the other hand, can, through disease or jealousy. Like other animals, we need to observe certain restrictions when it comes to sex.

In the Bible, sex is reserved for marriage. And most human societies agree. Within marriage, sex is important for the health of the relationship. In fact, the first commandment in the Bible is for humanity to be fruitful and multiply. The Song of Songs is a very sensual poem of married love. Sex is a gift from God and as Paul said, everything created by God is good, provided it is received with thankfulness, and sanctified by God’s word and prayer. That‘s what we do when we bless a wedding.

And it goes without saying, that sex should always be loving and never humiliating, degrading or harmful. As our prayer book says, marriage is meant for the couple’s mutual joy.

We have other needs as well, needs that are not physical. Some are social, like belonging to a family or group. Others are spiritual. Some scientists think that because belief in God is universal it must have an evolutionary advantage, something that caused humans who had it to thrive and the humans who didn’t to die off. They think it has to do with ensuring that people cooperate with one another. In fact, studies show that when reminded of God, people tend to be kind and helpful even to those outside their own family or group. It works better than simply being reminded of religion in general.

Belief in God activates several specific parts of the brain and brain chemicals. The evidence shows that, contrary to what some non-believers think, belief in God is normal and natural. We are hardwired for it.

But does that make it good? As we’ve seen in regards to certain biological urges, just because something occurs in nature or is the norm, that doesn’t necessarily make it good or beneficial. But belief in God has been clinically shown to reduce anxiety and promote healing and good physical health.

Neglecting our spiritual lives is bad for us in the same way that neglecting exercise or good hygiene is. It may not kill you as quickly as neglecting to eat, but overall it takes a toll on our spiritual and even physical health. In a study of women 50 years old and up, those who attend religious services weekly were 20% less likely to die in any given year. Religious observance is associated with 2 to 3 years of additional life. That’s on par with taking statin drugs for cholesterol.

Can you, as with eating, overdo religion? Yes. Studies show that people who only go to religious services get not only health and personal benefits but are kind and helpful to other members of their group. However, they are also more likely to think and act negatively towards those outside their faith. Jesus denounced the Pharisees who got so caught up in the minutiae of religion that they lost track of its most basic principles of justice and compassion to the marginalized and outsiders. Those same studies show that people who have a strong prayer life as well, those who have a direct relationship with God, are more altruistic to all people, including those who don’t belong to their faith or ethnic group. So it is vital to be connected not just with a religious group but with God himself.

We are amphibians, C.S. Lewis said, adapted to live in both the spiritual and physical worlds. We are not meant to live exclusively in either, so balance is important. The best way to do that is to obey the 2 great commandments Jesus laid out. By loving God, we stay in touch with the source of spiritual health, and by loving our neighbor as ourselves we stay connected with the physical world. As James reminds us, faith must manifest itself in the physical world as works to be genuine. As I’ve said before, the physical gives expression to the spiritual and the spiritual gives meaning to the physical. In that sense, our every action in this world should be sacramental, a giving of spiritual grace in some concrete form.

We need to reject the false dichotomy between the spiritual and the physical. When we try to divorce them, or overemphasize one at the expense of the other, we get into trouble. They are meant to go together in harmony. Sin and temptation, especially the temptation to oversimplify the situation, make achieving this balance hard but not impossible.

Above all, we must do everything in love and with gratitude to the God who created the world and everything in it as good gifts to be used wisely for the good of all. Or sometimes just enjoyed for what they are: physical expressions of his love.

Wednesday, November 17, 2010

The Gospel According to Everyone

It was a very dramatic way to begin an episode of “Star Trek: The Next Generation.” The crew no sooner detects a temporal anomaly in space than another Federation ship comes out of nowhere, hits the Enterprise and they both explode into tiny bits. Cue the opening title sequence and theme music.

After the first break, we are back on the Enterprise before their fatal crash. We see a little more of that day and then the catastrophe repeats itself. And we go to a commercial again. The whole episode goes that way except that during each iteration the crew begins to get clues that something is out of whack. Besides everyone experiencing massive amounts of déjà vu, the number 3 keeps popping up: in their traditional card game, in computer diagnostics, everywhere. But the end result is always the same: the other ship rockets towards them and both ships explode. By the final repeat of events, they are starting to piece together what is happening. They are in a time loop. And they are trying to figure out what they can do differently to avoid getting stuck in the same sequence of events. Should they avoid the anomaly? What if avoiding it is what triggered it all? They are second guessing everything, especially the significance of the recurrent appearances of the number 3. When the other ship appears and they have seconds to act, both Data and Commander Riker are at the helm and make hurried suggestions to get the Enterprise out of the way of an imminent head-on collision. Captain Picard orders the logical android to carry out his suggestion. But just as he is about to punch the necessary buttons, Data notices Riker’s rank insignia: 3 pips. He intuits that Riker’s idea is the correct one and follows it instead. The Enterprise narrowly escapes hitting the phantom ship. Later they check the ship’s chronometer with Star Fleet’s and realize they have been in the time loop for 17 days. When they hail the other ship, it turns out they have been missing for 80 years! Data figures that during one of their unsuccessful attempt to abort the collision, in the split second before the explosion,he encoded the number 3, Riker’s rank insignia, into his positronic brain. When the loop repeated, the number leaked out into everything he did. Its frequency drew attention to the clue which indicated the person who knew how to save them.

What if humanity kept getting itself into a series of disasters by making the wrong choices? What if you were God and wanted to save them? What if they didn’t have a universal translator like the Enterprise but hundreds of languages and cultures and religions? How would you encode the clue to the person who could save them?

You might do what Data did: insert a meme, a persistent idea that would pop up everywhere, into their brains. The best place for it to manifest itself would be in their stories. Every culture tells stories of the hero’s journey, in which he is called to adventure, given supernatural aid, heads off on the journey, faces temptation and challenges, undergoes literal or metaphorical death and resurrection, wins a victory, is transformed, returns to his people with a great boon. Joseph Campbell called this the monomyth, the basic story that underlies the stories of countless cultures. It is the basic structure of many Greek, Roman and Mesopotamian myths and specifically the stories of Osiris, Prometheus, and Buddha. It also sounds a lot like the life of Jesus Christ.

Because of that, some people think Jesus is either fictional or that the gospel writers changed his story to make it fit this pattern. But that takes a level of literary awareness not found in the gospels. C.S. Lewis was a professor of literature who studied the myths of other cultures, in the original languages when possible. He said the gospels were not as well written as the myths. They struck him as reportage. But he did see the similarities and one of the things that led Lewis to become a Christian was that he became convinced that in Christ, myth became fact. The existence of pagan stories of dying and rising gods didn’t bother him. If the gospel were true, if this was God’s plan, then we should expect him to grant these prophesies even to pagans. “Good dreams” Lewis called them.

Joseph Campbell listed 17 stages in this universal hero’s journey. Few myths have all of them. Let’s see how close these pagan prophesies come to describing the gospel.

The first stage is the call to adventure. The hero is called from his mundane life to go on a quest. The parallel would be John the Baptist’s announcement that the Kingdom of God is near. It is at this point that Jesus comes to John to be baptized and begins his ministry.
 

Next the hero receives supernatural aid from a mentor or helper. When Jesus comes up out of the water, the Holy Spirit descends on him. Jesus says that it is by the power of the Holy Spirit that he casts out demons.

The hero crosses the threshold from the mundane world into a unknown and dangerous realm. It leads to his transformation. After his baptism, Jesus is driven by the Spirit into the wilderness where he is tempted by the devil.

The hero walks the road of trials, facing tests he must overcome. As Jesus walks the roads of Galilee, he is tested by Pharisees, scribes and those who have no faith in him.

At this point the hero usually encounters a goddess or a temptress. The closest we have to this in the gospels is the woman taken in adultery and in a reversal on the myth, Jesus protects and forgives her.

At the center of the hero’s journey, he encounters the father with the power of life and death and makes atonement. The hero dies and is reborn. Jesus makes atonement for us with his Father by undergoing death on the cross and then rising again.

Having achieved his quest, the hero is granted the great boon he sought, often one that gives life or immortality. Through his death and resurrection, Jesus brings us life everlasting.

The hero returns over the threshold, sometimes facing further trials, and becomes the master of the two worlds. He achieves freedom from the fear of death. The trials Jesus faces after his resurrection is convincing his disciples to believe he has returned. They overcome their doubts and fears and proclaim him the Lord of heaven and earth.

Were it not for Jesus, the monomyth would be an interesting cross-cultural artifact, a oddly common story plot. But Jesus of Nazareth is real, a person in history. Paul’s earliest letters, written just 20 years after Jesus’ earthly life, already proclaim him as the Son of God who died for us and even mention 500 witnesses to his resurrection, most of whom are still alive at the time of the writing. The first gospel, written by Mark, the protégé of both Paul and Peter, will be written shortly after their martyrdoms. This is a mere 40 years after Jesus, well within the lifetime of witnesses who could contradict it.

Could what we have in writing have been altered or the truth lost over the years? We have literally thousands of early manuscripts with which to reconstruct the original texts. Look at the footnotes of any modern translation and you will see the variant reading, which are largely trivial. In addition we have hundreds of translations, which allows us to reconstruct the versions they were based on. Finally we have enough quotes in the early church fathers that we could construct the entire New Testament, except for 11 verses, from them alone. The only alternate gospels we have are more fantastical than the canonical 4. What we don't have is a demythologized account of Jesus. 


If we do not believe the writings of the New Testament, and the Jesus they describe, we must dismiss all ancient writings as well as the existence of all significant ancient individuals, such as Aristotle, Plato, Hippocrates, Pythagoras, and Archimedes. Because the gap between the earliest copies of their writings and the original manuscripts is not mere decades but 800 years or more. Throw out Jesus and you must also lose any reliable evidence of the beginnings of science and reason in ancient Greece.    

Historians know that Jesus was born somewhere between 7 and 4 BC. He was crucified about 30 AD. Within 20 years he was worshipped as divine in communities across the Roman Empire. 40 years after the first Easter most of his disciples had gone to their deaths, joyfully proclaiming his resurrection. If it weren’t true, it would be like a growing community of people proclaiming President Kennedy’s resurrection at this close an interval to his death. In contrast, the legend of King Arthur doesn’t arise until nearly 400 years after he might have lived. And in Arthur’s case we have documents that show us how the legend evolved and the sources from which the elements were drawn. To say the same thing happened with the gospels in a 10th of that time is to assert something for which there is no historical evidence and which in fact goes against all historical precedent.        

C.S. Lewis was right. In Jesus, this myth, whose variations cross all times and cultures, became a fact. God seeded the human psyche with the clues, so that we would recognize him who can save us. And the story so answers our needs that we still consciously or unconsciously use it to weave the modern myths we tell in movies, TV, and comic books. Superman, the creation of two Jewish young men, is a kind of messiah. So are Buffy the Vampire Slayer, Doctor Who, Sherlock Holmes, Neo, Mr. Spock, Luke Skywalker, Harry Potter, Aslan the lion and multiple characters in “The Lord of the Rings.” All these characters from pantheons past and present are clues leading us back to the original hero, Jesus Christ, who made the myth reality and calls us to the adventure of following him, offering us his aid through the tests and trials we encounter, and at the end of our journey, everlasting life in his kingdom.